B.J.'s Tombstone History Discussion Form

T.T.R. Oct 27 - 31, 2010

Tombstone History Discussion Forum

Link To Tombstone History Archives

Link To Tombstone High School & McLaury Family Scholarship Website.

Link To BJs Tombstone History Link's List

Link to Tombstone Vendetta

Link to "The Wild West History Association"

Link to The Wyatt Earp Birthplace located in Monmouth, Illinois

Link to TTR 2009 Photo Page

Internship in Deadwood — Nancy Pope, Thu Feb 4 06:39

Amer. Exp. had wrong date — Jeff Wheat, Wed Feb 3 10:05

PBS — Jim Dunham, Tue Feb 9 07:42
- I'm not complaining either but — Tom Gaumer, Tue Feb 9 11:17
- would you comment on ... — Richard Weddle, Tue Feb 9 10:43
Re: Amer. Exp. had wrong date — Jeff Isble, Sat Feb 6 16:14

"Tombstone" on Blu-ray May 4, 2010 — John K., Tue Feb 2 06:15

Turns out, Justice is Coming SOONER! — John K., Wed Feb 3 12:49
From what I have read.... — Michael F. Blake, Wed Feb 3 02:28
- Mike I believe you are right — Paul Cool, Wed Feb 3 07:12
good thing too — p cool, Tue Feb 2 10:40
- with regard to sales — Richard Weddle, Sun Feb 7 20:04
- Tombstone's one-liners — p cool, Tue Feb 2 10:45
- - check out Jarre's previous western — Richard Weddle, Mon Feb 8 04:51
  - - Thanks for the heads up... — Geraldo, Mon Feb 8 14:26
    - - singular not plural. — Richard Weddle, Tue Feb 9 11:45

Art of the pistol engraver on display — Jen, Mon Feb 1 15:11

Re: Art of the pistol engraver on display — Jeff Isble, Tue Feb 2 15:43
Dodge City Cowboy Band — Steve Sanders, Mon Feb 1 17:45
- Re: Dodge City Cowboy Band — Jen, Tue Feb 2 06:08
- - Thanks Jen. So much grist here.. — Steve Sanders, Tue Feb 2 11:20

Adios, Allie — Jen, Sun Jan 31 19:41

Re: Adios, Allie — K.t.K., Sun Jan 31 21:51
- Yep — Sneaky Pete, Mon Feb 1 04:59
Didn't John Clum own the Epitaph? — Devil's Advocate, Sun Jan 31 20:51
- Re: Didn't John Clum own the Epitaph? — Bob Cash, Mon Feb 1 18:49
- - Bob... your memory is partially correct... — Gary Ledoux, Sun Feb 7 20:59
  - - What about Nellis Cashman? — Fred Dodge, Mon Feb 8 12:32
    - - Sorry Nellie Cashman (nm) — Fred Dodge, Mon Feb 8 12:32
      - Nellie was somewhat of an... — Gary Ledoux, Mon Feb 8 18:59

TV Western Themes — Michael F. Blake, Sun Jan 31 15:46

PBS documentary WYATT EARP on DVD February 23 — Richard Weddle, Thu Jan 28 11:31

American Experience: Wyatt Earp DVD available now — John K., Sun Feb 7 07:10
where did Wyatt say -- — Richard Weddle, Thu Jan 28 12:37
- not the answer, but rollicking read — Daniel Buck, Thu Jan 28 13:24
- - Re: not the answer, but rollicking read — Keith, Mon Feb 1 13:47
  - How do you find these things, Dan? — Pam Potter, Thu Jan 28 14:24
  - - It was hilarious. — Jen, Thu Jan 28 17:22
    - "THC" doesnt always mean The History Channel (nm) — Steve Sanders, Thu Jan 28 15:07
    - it found me — Daniel Buck, Thu Jan 28 14:55
    - - ahem ... — Richard Weddle, Thu Jan 28 16:54
      - The Book of Wyatt — Daniel Buck, Thu Jan 28 18:38
        
        S. J. Reidhead article — J-Dog, Thu Jan 28 23:54
        
        Luke Short — SJ Reidhead, Sun Feb 7 21:00
        
        Hi Sarah Jane — Peter Christoph, Sun Feb 7 21:32
        
        Re: Luke Short — Richard Weddle, Sun Feb 7 21:26
        
        no sources — Richard Weddle, Sun Feb 7 18:32
        
        Wyatt Line... — SJ Reidhead, Sun Feb 7 21:02
        
        many thanks, S.J. (nm) — Richard Weddle, Sun Feb 7 21:28

Might I change the focus of the PBS — sharonc, Thu Jan 28 08:29

Doc and Mattie — Gary Roberts, Thu Jan 28 10:52
- Re: Doc and Mattie — Robin Andrews, Thu Jan 28 14:30
- HI, Gary. Yes, it does help. — sharonc, Thu Jan 28 11:03
- - None I'm aware of. (nm) — Gary Roberts, Thu Jan 28 12:47

Dallas suggestions? — bfrey, Wed Jan 27 13:59

Not much to Dallas as far as Old West is — James Wright, Wed Jan 27 16:30
- cartwright-storm gunfight — bfrey, Wed Jan 27 20:20
- - You mean he Luke Short vs. Jim Courtright duel.... — K.t.K., Wed Jan 27 21:13
  - - yes that one..... — bfrey, Thu Jan 28 06:34
    - - Fort Worth connection. — K.t.K., Thu Jan 28 08:48
      - thanks K (nm) — bfrey, Thu Jan 28 09:03

PBS' Wyatt Earp — Roger Jay, Tue Jan 26 14:42

Question....? — Jeff Morey, Wed Jan 27 11:32
- Re: Question....? — Roger Jay, Wed Jan 27 14:06
- - Well.... — Jeff Morey, Thu Jan 28 11:51
  - - Re: Well.... — Roger Jay, Thu Jan 28 17:59
    - - It seemed to me that..... — Jeff Morey, Fri Jan 29 12:24
      - Re: It seemed to me that..... — Roger Jay, Fri Jan 29 14:17
        
        A guestion is begged.... — Jeff Morey, Sat Jan 30 13:27
        
        Re: A guestion is begged.... — Roger Jay, Tue Feb 2 11:08
        
        Yes.... — Jeff Morey, Thu Feb 4 05:54
  - Never infer short of certainty — Keith, Wed Jan 27 15:09
  - - Keith, would you be so kind,,, — Roger Jay, Thu Jan 28 08:48
    - - Re: Keith, would you be so kind,,, — Anonymous, Mon Feb 1 13:03
      - Nice post, Keith — Roger Jay, Tue Feb 2 11:33
        
        Again anonymous was me NM (nm) — Keith, Mon Feb 1 13:19
An "I loved it but" moment — Roger Jay, Wed Jan 27 10:26
- In the middle of all that shooting is it not possible — Tom Gaumer, Wed Jan 27 12:14
- - Re: In the middle of all that shooting is it not possible — Roger Jay, Wed Jan 27 14:20
  - - Re: In the middle of all that shooting is it not possible — Tom Gaumer, Wed Jan 27 16:55
    - - Re: In the middle of all that shooting is it not possible — Roger Jay, Thu Jan 28 08:40
      - Yes. I think Mr. Huttons conclusion is possible. — Tom Gaumer, Fri Jan 29 00:41
        
        Re: Yes. I think Mr. Huttons conclusion is possible. — Roger Jay, Fri Jan 29 08:40
        
        Thanks for the discussion Roger — Tom Gaumer, Fri Jan 29 20:40
        
        the fantasy of the "incredible presence of mind" — Richard Weddle, Thu Jan 28 10:51
        
        I question "running" — Peter Christoph, Fri Jan 29 09:35
        
        Re: the fantasy of the "incredible presence of mind" — Roger Jay, Thu Jan 28 18:17
        
        Re: the fantasy of the "incredible presence of mind" — Richard Weddle, Sun Feb 7 18:54
        
        Probably need every round — p cool, Tue Feb 9 11:30
        
        Re: In the middle of all that shooting is it not possible — John K., Thu Jan 28 10:00
        
        Your words seem reasonable to me also — Anonymous, Thu Jan 28 13:37
        
        Define "grapple" — John K., Fri Jan 29 05:46
        
        So, Wyatt and Ike were indulging in an interesting — Tom Gaumer, Fri Jan 29 20:46
Thanks a bunch, Roger. 100% agreement. — K.t.K., Tue Jan 26 15:39
- Re: Thanks a bunch, Roger. 100% agreement. — Anonymous, Tue Jan 26 15:59
- - Anonymous was Keith NM (nm) — Keith, Tue Jan 26 15:59
Good, thoughtful post. Thanks Roger — Paul Cool, Tue Jan 26 15:26
- more on Earp and Hollywood.. — Roger Peterson, Tue Jan 26 16:53
- - wrong string — roger peterson, Tue Jan 26 17:05

PBS American Experience/Earp — Roger Peterson, Mon Jan 25 23:13

Re: PBS American Experience/Earp — Keith, Tue Jan 26 15:35
Need to watch it again — John K., Tue Jan 26 05:27
- Second viewing — Geraldo, Tue Jan 26 18:36
- - To answer your question... — Roger Jay, Tue Jan 26 21:03
- Full show is online at PBS.ORG — John K., Tue Jan 26 08:39
Class Act — Pam Potter, Tue Jan 26 00:57
- I thought it was okay..... — Michael F. Blake, Tue Jan 26 03:19
- - Mike, there's never a "just" in your two cents (nm) — p cool, Tue Jan 26 04:04
  - - Enjoyed it... but. — Fred Dodge, Tue Jan 26 12:06
    - - Pretty good.. — Steve Sanders, Tue Jan 26 12:46
      - PBS Wyatt — Peter Christoph, Tue Jan 26 13:29
        
        A+ Documentary on Wyatt — Larry K, Tue Jan 26 14:17
        
        A+ Documentary — Cary Eberly, Tue Jan 26 23:51
        
        A+? Gimme a break. — K.t.K., Tue Jan 26 15:42
        
        How about A if you grade on a curve in — Tom Gaumer, Wed Jan 27 00:02
        
        Better yet,... — K.t.K., Wed Jan 27 07:57
        
        Much of that was speculative but here is a good one — Tom Gaumer, Wed Jan 27 10:16
        
        B at best — Cathy Spude, Tue Jan 26 17:04
        
        Photos — Pam Potter, Tue Jan 26 19:44
        
        "You Are There" — Richard Weddle, Tue Jan 26 22:50
        
        You Are There - again — Geraldo, Wed Jan 27 09:54
        
        Re: You Are There - again — Pam Potter, Wed Jan 27 14:55
        
        That program.... — Michael F. Blake, Wed Jan 27 13:46
        
        Re: You Are There - again — Richard Weddle, Wed Jan 27 10:59
        
        Re: You Are There - again — Steve Hartley, Wed Jan 27 12:07
        
        Isenberg on Nicholas Earp — Roger Peterson, Tue Jan 26 17:58
        
        ? — Richard Weddle, Tue Jan 26 18:29
        
        Isenberg article last spring — Roger Peterson, Tue Jan 26 20:14
        
        Homosocial — Anne Collier, Tue Jan 26 20:30
        
        Re: Homosocial — Richard Weddle, Tue Jan 26 21:17
        
        Supposition error — Anne Collier, Tue Jan 26 21:42
        
        Isenberg's thesis — Roger Peterson, Thu Jan 28 08:39
        
        Re: Supposition error — Keith, Wed Jan 27 14:34
        
        Nicholas Earp "bully." — K.t.K., Wed Jan 27 21:43
        
        Re: Nicholas Earp "bully." — Keith, Mon Feb 1 13:17
        
        Re: Nicholas Earp "bully." — Roger Jay, Fri Jan 29 14:37
        
        Don't tell me... — K.t.K., Fri Jan 29 15:58
        
        no worries — Richard Weddle, Tue Jan 26 22:55
        
        No worries here either — Anne Collier, Thu Jan 28 01:01
        
        Isenberg on homosociality — Cathy Spude, Wed Jan 27 11:35
        
        Homoerotic? Yee howdy! — Anne Collier, Thu Jan 28 00:57
        
        What kind of board is this? (nm) — Virgil, Tue Feb 9 08:57
        
        Innuendo — Steve Sanders, Tue Jan 26 18:12
        
        Where is JOYCE, when we need her? (nm) — K.t.K., Tue Jan 26 22:15
        
        KtK/ where? — Joyce Aros, Thu Jan 28 05:13
        
        Do you have a way to play video tapes? — Tom Gaumer, Fri Jan 29 00:57
        
        Tom/videos — Joyce Aros, Fri Jan 29 04:38
        
        Joyce, you can have mine — Richard Weddle, Thu Jan 28 15:37
        
        Richard/8 shelves! — Joyce Aros, Fri Jan 29 04:43
        
        Joyce/where? — Bob Paul, Thu Jan 28 12:56
        
        Bob/PBS — Joyce Aros, Fri Jan 29 04:47
        
        Hi Joyce. — K.t.K., Fri Jan 29 08:41
        
        I have never posted here before, but I am puzzled. — William Gillespie, Mon Feb 1 13:02
        
        Gillespie/heroes — Joyce Aros, Tue Feb 2 05:30
        
        heroes? — Richard Weddle, Sun Feb 7 19:51
        
        On what basis do you label Frank and Tom Stage coach robbers (nm — Tom Gaumer, Sun Feb 7 21:58
        
        freedom from any and all government interference? — Paul Cool, Mon Feb 1 13:42
        
        Re: Hi Joyce. — Anonymous, Sat Jan 30 18:30
        
        Re: Hi Joyce. — K.t.K., Sat Jan 30 22:31
        
        Hi KtK — Peter Christoph, Wed Feb 3 06:35
        
        "Anonymous" is me (nm) — Peter Christoph, Sat Jan 30 18:31
        
        KtK/Great minds...... — Joyce Aros, Fri Jan 29 17:18
        
        Go for it. — K.t.K., Fri Jan 29 20:36
        
        Re: Joyce/where? — Mark Dworkin, Thu Jan 28 14:42
        
        Mark/pure enjoyment — Joyce Aros, Fri Jan 29 04:50

R. I. P Adam Cartwright (nm) — Jen, Mon Jan 25 20:39

Oh no — Pam Potter, Mon Jan 25 20:50
- Pernell Roberts — Gary Roberts, Tue Jan 26 07:04

Whetstone nuggets — Lynn Bailey, Mon Jan 25 13:26

Anything good on TV tonight? — John K., Mon Jan 25 05:32

Ya, I think American Bachelor is on — Steve Sanders, Mon Jan 25 11:17

John Wayne does Noel Coward — Paul Cool, Sat Jan 23 04:38

splendid — Daniel Buck, Sat Jan 23 06:39
- I have a problem with this story.... — Michael F. Blake, Sat Jan 23 14:20
- - great stories & dodgy memories — Daniel Buck, Sat Jan 23 17:04
  - Maybe it was the film he got wrong — p cool, Sat Jan 23 14:56
  - - Re: Maybe it was the film he got wrong — Jeff Isble, Sun Jan 24 12:13
    - - Re: Maybe it was the film he got wrong — Steve Hartley, Sun Jan 24 18:08
      - Re: Maybe it was the film he got wrong — Jeff Isble, Tue Jan 26 16:16
      - "thou art beautiful in thy wrath" — p cool, Sun Jan 24 16:15
    - born wearing chaps? — Daniel Buck, Sat Jan 23 18:38
    - - Re: born wearing chaps? — Richard Weddle, Sat Jan 23 19:04
      - Wayne's disarming manner — Daniel Buck, Sat Jan 23 19:31
        
        Re: Wayne's disarming manner — Richard Weddle, Sat Jan 23 20:23

Az State Parks — judge, Fri Jan 22 21:56

Re: Az State Parks — Ricahrd Weddle, Sat Jan 23 09:14
- Attn: Richard Weddle — judge, Sun Jan 24 20:03
- - send lawyers, guns, and money — Richard Weddle, Wed Jan 27 15:18

Richard Erwin's Wyatt Earp Book — BRW, Thu Jan 21 23:42

Re: Richard Erwin's Wyatt Earp Book — Richard Weddle, Fri Jan 22 09:02

today's Supreme Court ruling — Richard Weddle, Thu Jan 21 19:12

RIP Robert B. Parker — Sarah Stegall, Tue Jan 19 17:43

Re: RIP Robert B. Parker — Richard Weddle, Tue Jan 19 18:32

"Earp was in real-life more a baddie than a lawman" — Mark Dworkin, Mon Jan 18 23:21

Baddies — mdinaz, Tue Jan 19 19:42
- Re: Baddies — K.t.K., Wed Jan 20 06:52
- - Well then — mdinaz, Wed Jan 20 19:25
  - - Re: Well then — Pam Potter, Wed Jan 20 22:47
    - - Sorry — Gary Roberts, Thu Jan 21 09:54
      - Searching "Jeff Smith" is a picnic...lol. (nm) — Jeff Smith, Thu Jan 21 11:41
  - Kenny, you BTW (Bill Tilghman Worshipper)... — Bob Cash, Wed Jan 20 18:25
  - - Had to put that behind me, Bob... — K.t.K., Wed Jan 20 19:00
That's what I want, a "fragrant memory" (nm) — p cool, Tue Jan 19 07:16

Mescal Spring archaeology? — J-Dog, Mon Jan 18 22:36

Casings — mdinaz, Tue Jan 19 19:43
- Proof? — J-Dog, Tue Jan 19 20:49
- - Galeyville book — Fred Dodge, Wed Jan 20 09:09
  - I, too, am looking . . . — Lynn Bailey, Wed Jan 20 06:25
  - - Yes,... — Mark Dworkin, Wed Jan 20 19:00
    - - “Not to divulge” . . . What? — Lynn Bailey, Thu Jan 21 04:30
      - where will the report be published? — Richard Weddle, Wed Jan 20 19:51
    - As with authors in their research. . . — Gary Roberts, Wed Jan 20 10:13
    - - I “have no basis for questioning . . . — Lynn Bailey, Wed Jan 20 10:58
      - Archaeology in the Whetstones — Robin Andrews, Thu Jan 21 15:19
        
        Armchair General — Lynn Bailey, Thu Jan 21 15:38
        
        For the record — Gary Roberts, Thu Jan 21 08:54
        
        Re: I “have no basis for questioning . . . — eric.weider 354, Thu Jan 21 07:57
        
        Eric Weider — Richard Weddle, Thu Jan 21 12:37
        
        I appreciate your response (nm) — Lynn Bailey, Thu Jan 21 12:06
        
        Re: I “have no basis for questioning . . . — Richard Weddle, Thu Jan 21 09:26
        
        Re: I “have no basis for questioning . . . — Anonymous, Thu Jan 21 10:07
        
        Thanks Lynn — J-Dog, Thu Jan 21 22:45
        
        No disrespect taken, J-dog. — Cathy Spude, Sat Jan 23 11:33
        
        Scott investigation — J-Dog, Sat Jan 23 12:36
        
        Ooops — J-Dog, Thu Jan 21 22:47

Wyatt Earp PBS — Tombstonian, Sat Jan 16 18:04

okay, I was impressed — Richard Weddle, Mon Jan 25 22:26
another icon bites the dust — Richard Weddle, Sun Jan 17 13:01
- Re: another icon bites the dust — Steve Hartley, Mon Jan 18 17:55
- Who is responsible for the historical perspective? Well... — John K., Mon Jan 18 10:23
- - ... into the fire — Richard Weddle, Mon Jan 18 10:34
  - - Re: ... into the fire — Pam Potter, Mon Jan 18 12:23
    - - editing makes all the difference — Richard Weddle, Mon Jan 18 14:09
    - watch the entire program — Daniel Buck, Mon Jan 18 10:51
    - - historians have little influence — William Urban, Tue Jan 19 07:30
      - facts, legends, and documentaries — Richard Weddle, Tue Jan 19 10:01
        
        How much would an hour long history show cost? — Tom Gaumer, Tue Jan 19 11:55
        
        why don't you PM me — Richard Weddle, Tue Jan 19 16:08
        
        What stops historians from making a TV show themselves? — Tom Gaumer, Tue Jan 19 09:20
        
        What stops historians from making shows? — mdinaz, Tue Jan 19 19:51
        
        Another thing you have to consider.... — Michael F. Blake, Wed Jan 20 13:35
        
        reconsidered — Richard Weddle, Fri Jan 22 13:57
        
        I agree. — mdinaz, Wed Jan 20 19:44
        
        Thadd Turner is a historian who made a movie. — Tom Gaumer, Wed Jan 20 10:38
        
        Thadd Turner is NOT... — Michael F. Blake, Wed Jan 20 13:30
        
        Thadd did research and wrote a book about his subject — Tom Gaumer, Wed Jan 20 16:20
        
        True, but ... — Richard Weddle, Wed Jan 20 15:03
        
        I'm suggesting the historians become the production company — Tom Gaumer, Tue Jan 19 22:47
        
        That would be great, but ... — mdinaz, Wed Jan 20 19:43
        
        Tom...It can happen.... — Gary S. McLelland, Wed Jan 20 18:49
        
        How much money is an interesting question — Tom Gaumer, Wed Jan 20 22:55
        
        We have contacted... — Gary S. McLelland, Fri Jan 22 07:34
        
        Will do Gary but maybe the show on Monday night — Tom Gaumer, Fri Jan 22 08:53
        
        Tom...e-mail "tombstonem@comcast.net" (nm) — Gary S. McLelland, Thu Jan 21 07:10
        
        Done (nm) — Tom Gaumer, Fri Jan 22 08:51
      - I'll hope for the best — Richard Weddle, Mon Jan 18 11:20
      - Not all advice is taken in TV — Roger Peterson, Wed Jan 20 00:02
        
        Re: Not all advice is taken in TV — Richard Weddle, Wed Jan 20 09:10

For Roger Peterson — Bob Cash, Sat Jan 16 12:38

Re: For Roger Peterson — Bob Cash, Sat Jan 16 13:33
- Bob, thanks,,, — Roger Peterson, Thu Jan 21 00:04

Johnny Ringo, Deputy — Pam Potter, Fri Jan 15 23:27

The new deputy in town. — Robin Andrews, Sat Jan 16 12:41

Earp's web biography — Casey Tefertiller, Fri Jan 15 19:38

Well, they do acknowledge that it's a parody. — Tom Bryant, Fri Jan 15 19:58

forum hosted by Billy Johnson.

earpmorgan at aol.com

established 4/10/99

Best Buy Coupons