Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
Israel employs diplomacy in bid to curb human rights groups
Sun Jul 26, 2015 05:01

Israel employs diplomacy in bid to curb human rights groups

With legislative attempts often blocked, Foreign Ministry tries to go to the source in ongoing effort to prevent foreign funding of NGOs


Deputy Foreign Minister Tzipi Hotovely unveiled last week the latest attempt in an ongoing right-wing struggle to prevent foreign funding of Israeli human rights organizations.

Get The Times of Israel's Daily Edition by email
and never miss our top stories Free Sign up!

In the past, right-wing politicians — mainly from the Yisrael Beytenu, Likud and Jewish Home parties — attempted to stem the flow of government euros to Israeli non-governmental organizations through legislation. Hotovely, however, plans to accomplish the same feat through diplomacy.

Hotovely, a Likud legislator who functions as Israel’s de facto top diplomat in the absence of a dedicated foreign minister, announced on Tuesday that she had met with representatives of several EU countries to convince them to end their government’s funding of NGOs that “work to blacken Israel’s name in the world.”

If the individual governments and the European Union do not voluntary cease funding these groups, Hotovely threatened, Israel may fall back on legislation to outlaw the practice.

Israel already requires NGOs to declare if they receive funding from governments abroad. As a Knesset member, Immigrant Absorption Minister Ze’ev Elkin (Likud) sponsored the Foreign Government NGO Funding Transparency Bill, which passed in early 2011 and requires groups to state the source of foreign funding on advertisements and declare if they are forced to adopt political stances in exchange for the money.

The bill passed with support from both sides of the aisle and even with minimal argument from the NGOs themselves, which by and large were already open about their donors, Dr. Amir Fuchs of the Israel Democracy Institute told The Times of Israel.

Hotovely’s proposal, however, will be far more contentious.
Keeping government euros out of NGOs’ hands

In a tweet, the 36-year-old Likud MK said she told foreign diplomats, “We need to put an end to the funding of organizations that delegitimize Israel under the guise of human rights NGOs.”

In his tenure as foreign minister, Yisrael Beytenu MK Avigdor Liberman went even further in his assessment of human rights groups such as B’Tselem, Breaking the Silence and the Adalah Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel, calling them “terror organizations.”

Yisrael Beytenu head Avigdor Liberman (Miriam Alster/Flash90)

Liberman, whose party in 2011 attempted to form a government probe to investigate human rights groups, said at the time, “These are neither left-wing organizations nor human rights organizations; they are terrorist organizations — groups that abet terror and people who actively participate in abetting terror.”

The Yisrael Beytenu-proposed committee was quickly and soundly defeated in the Knesset, with some detractors at the time referring to it as “along the lines of Joseph McCarthy,” a reference to the infamous American senator who headed the House Un-American Activities Committee, which persecuted those citizens believed to be communist conspirators and sympathizers in the 1950s.

Nevertheless, MK Yinon Magal of Yisrael Beytenu continued his party’s campaign to restrict foreign funding with a proposal last month that would require any organization that receives more than $50,000 from a foreign government to pay a 37 percent tax on those donations and force those groups to clearly identify themselves as foreign organizations.

Under Magal’s proposal, “every official document, website, sign or publication” would have to identify them as foreign organizations, covering “no less than one-eighth of the page or area.”
MK Yinon Magal leaves a press conference after a meeting with President Reuven Rivlin at the President’s Residence in Jerusalem on March 22, 2015 (Hadas Parush/Flash90)

Similar proposals to halt foreign countries’ funding over the years have been struck down by the attorney general for being discriminatory against left-wing organizations.

For the most part, Fuchs explained, “right-wing organizations get money from individuals and left-wing groups are funded by countries.”

Prof. Gerald Steinberg, founder of the organization NGO Monitor and a political science professor at Bar Ilan University, sees the distinction between foreign and private funding as critical.

Foreign funding of these organizations, he said, is an infringement upon Israeli sovereignty.

“Governments are sovereign entities. Sovereignty is exclusive. You cannot have a situation where two countries exercise sovereignty,” Steinberg said. “Private individuals are governed in an entirely different way.”

He added, “The only comparison is that they both give money.”

Fuchs, on the other hand, does not see a meaningful difference between state and private funding. “I’m not convinced,” he said.

The only distinction between the two types of funding that Fuchs did recognize was that the motivations of the donor are more apparent when it comes from a government.

“A private individual,” he explained, “we know nothing about,” whereas the Western European governments donating to these groups are “friendly countries, like the UK,” he said.

Several countries around the world have what are known as “foreign agent” laws, which require organizations that receive funding from abroad to clearly identify themselves as operating under those auspices.

The United States has had such a law since the 1930s, though the extent to which it is enforced has waxed and waned over the decades.

Unlike Hotovely’s and other right-wing politicians’ proposals, however, this “foreign agent” status is also given to NGOs and lobbying groups that receive funding from individuals, and not just foreign governments.

Steinberg, who supports Hotovely’s effort, added that he would encourage a similar requirement for Israeli NGOs receiving funding from private individuals as well.

“If somebody wants to bring up the issue of private funding — funding from [George] Soros, funding from the Rockefeller brothers, funding from [Sheldon] Adelson — that’s also legitimate,” Steinberg said

But, he added, “those are not the same discussions” as the issue of funding from foreign governments.
The NGOs respond

The organizations that stand to be affected by Hotovely’s diplomatic pressure on European governments denounced her plan and the allegation that they seek to delegitimize Israel.
B’Tselem director Hagai El-Ad (screen capture: YouTube)

Hagai El-Ad, CEO of B’Tselem, said that the deputy foreign minister’s plan for NGOs and her recent decision to require foreign dignitaries to visit the Old City of Jerusalem “will not convince [these diplomats] to support the occupation and settlements.”

He added, “Hotovely does not have the measurement tool to determine who is ‘harmful’ and who is ‘harmless’ to the country.

“No matter what, B’Tselem will continue its work to expose human rights violations in the territories,” El-Ad said.

Shai Grunberg, spokesperson for the Gisha organization, which principally advocates for the freedom of movement of Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, told The Times of Israel, “Gisha is a human rights organization that operates alongside and with the proper authorities. Our activities are public and encourage transparency.”

Finally, she added, her organization’s work not only does not delegitimize Israel, but “will help give legitimacy to Israel in the community of nations.”

Valerie Jean
Well, well...Israel should also keep foreign funding out of its elections. According to the Israeli comptroller's office, in Netanyahu’s last three elections publicly available records show that he has consistently received more than 90% of his campaign contributions from the United States. Bennett tops Netty with 97% of his campaign funds from America. These guys can't raise money at home? This should be worrisome to those who fear foreign influence.

Israel should further keep foreign funding out of ALL its non-profit organizations. "Israel relies to an astonishing degree on foreign donation...See More
Like · Reply · 2 hrs

Yochanan Michael
Valerie Helga,
stop profanng a Jewish name. It doesnt raise your IQ 15-30 points to a Jewish level.
Like · Reply · 1 · 1 hr
Valerie Jean

Yochanan Michael You have nothing worthwhile to say... again.
Like · Reply · 1 hr

Tom Lawrence
Valerie Jean I got the same remark. This "thing" is either a parrot or a monkey, I'm not sure which. It's probably the same lunatic that posts "hit lists" on Jerusalem Post comments. grin emoticon
Like · Reply · 1 · 54 mins
Tom Lawrence

Why not just bomb them??
Like · Reply · 2 · 3 hrs

Yochanan Michael
Reinhard Lawrence,
stop profanng a Jewish name. It doesnt raise your IQ 15-30 points to a Jewish level.
Like · Reply · 1 hr

Karl Pfeifer · Vienna, Austria
Like · Reply · 3 hrs
Miriam Cohen · Works at Librarian
"Human rights" groups? I can't believe that the Times of Israel uses this term with no quote marks. The only "human rights" these groups are interested in are the Palestinians.. and the only entity that they are ready to condemn and boycott is Israel.
Like · Reply · 4 hrs

Ralph Haglund · Lund University
Good that she is kicking on what should have been kicked down long time ago. To read NGO monitor, makes you think of the nazi age.
Like · Reply · 4 hrs

Robert Taylor · Works at Retired
One might take issue with the phrase "in the absence of a dedicated foreign minister." OK, I know what it it meant--but someone MIGHT misconstrue it to imply "lack of dedication"--and this lady--whatever ELSE she may be--is DEFINITELY DEDICATED!
Like · Reply · 4 hrs

Harvey Stein · A Third Way (feature documentary) at Director/Co-Producer
Absurd and hypocritical - rich U.S. Jews fund settler activities (often by giving to U.S. non-profits that then pass the money to Israel), to the tune of $$multimillions. And we all know that Israel's FREE right wing paper, Yisroel HaYom, which is essentially a mouthpiece for Bibi, is entirely funded by that sleazy American Jewish billionaire, who has made his money in casinos worldwide (where prostitution is often part of the package deals), Sheldon Adelson....
Like · Reply · 5 · 5 hrs

Robert Taylor · Works at Retired
Harvey, you might arguably have been just a wee tad harsh on Uncle Sheldon--but keep in mind that--according to studies just out--US Jews are growing increasingly less enamoured of some of the Israeli policies and actions that he backs--and THAT, friend, is a seemingly-growing trend that could have quite significant ramifications for a LOT of "stuff." (all the best!)
Like · Reply · 2 · 5 hrs

Harvey Stein · A Third Way (feature documentary) at Director/Co-Producer
Robert - it's almost impossibly to be too harsh on a shrivelled billionaire who made his bucks capitalizing on peoples' lowest desires! So now it's a battle between his $50 million investment against BDS etc, and the peoples' changing views - the power of clearer thinking version money - a frequent battle thse days!
Like · Reply · 2 · 5 hrs

James Martin
Governments are elected by the people Anderson elected himself,nkw go and cry on your mothers shoulder,pathetic comment
Like · Reply · 5 hrs
Robert Taylor · Works at Retired
Harvey, a couple thoughts:

1. Uncle Sheldon is NOT "shrivveled"--the guy's noticeably CHUBBY!

2. All through history, more money has been made catering to folks' "lowest desires"--than to their "highest" ones...Depressing, arguably; true, indubitably.
Like · Reply · 5 hrs

Yochanan Michael
but those are loyal Jewish Jews. Soroso like a good leftist, turned Jews into the nazi authorities.

  • Gov’t Official: Chilling report from Pacific Ocean… “Silence on the seas” — “Quite literally, there isn’t any fish” — Japan Professor: Fukushima posing reproduction risk to marine life, ongoing... more
    • Israel employs diplomacy in bid to curb human rights groups — PS POST, Sun Jul 26 05:01
    • UFO Hovered Over Neighbor’s Home 7-15-15PS POST, Sat Jul 25 05:27
      UFO Hovered Over Neighbor’s Home 7-15-15 By Roger Marsh 7-24-15 A Colorado witness at Commerce City reported watching “two bright red, disc-shaped” UFOs where one of the objects hovered... more
Click here to receive daily updates