Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
George E Proulx
Re: E22 References to Red 1
Thu Mar 1, 2018 16:38
24.113.165.214

Hi Tom, I am 70 years old now and having 'studied' this battle for most of my adult life I can appreciate the work we share at trying to understand all of the action. Knowing that the "extreme left" of Red 1 at the boundary of Red 2 was a well defended 'death trap' for almost all of the men who landed there in Tractor #44 as well as LVT-2 #2, #9 and probably others, it is hard for me to believe that a tractor actually got ashore and moved inland in that area especially lacking any photographic evidence. Having been in combat and in the sometimes confusing shifting of positions involved, I will always appreciate the labor of completing an SAR. All we can hope for then is a degree of accuracy that justifiably tells the story of those who were there. Thanks for the posting info.

  • E22 References to Red 1Tom Godwin, Thu Mar 1 09:04
    If of interest, these are the extracts from books re: E22 elements on Red 1. Other documentation shows that 1 platoon of Easy (the 1st Plt) , 1 from G and two from H all fought with Ryan's orphans.... more
    • RB1 and RB2 divide, a story...matt holly, Thu Mar 1 23:13
      Hey guys, I have an analysis of why the Marines ended up divided on this common approach, between RB1 and RB2 and should write a short story about it. It is a work in progress, so maybe within a few... more
    • Re: E22 References to Red 1 — George E Proulx, Thu Mar 1 16:38
      • Re: E22 Reference to Red 1Tom Godwin, Thu Mar 1 19:11
        Understand, respect and appreciate that 100% sir. As it stands, I'm certain that they fought from a crater. Hand-drawn picture from Lonnie, my father's citation, even a bond drive transcript from... more
Click here to receive daily updates