Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
Sprout
Destroying the Pyramids...
Tue Jul 10, 2012 1:16pm
192.86.118.96

While I consider it SOMEWHAT unlikely, there aparently has been some calling in Egypt for the destruction of the 'symbols of paganism' that the pre-Islamic relics represent. Not unlike the current destruction of pre-Islamic tombs in a few other places going on today.

So... here is the question. IF the Egyptian gov't, which has care, custody, control, and ownership of Giza decides to destroy the Pyramids, the Sphinx and other pre-Islamic sites in Egypt, should the rest of the world simply sit by? If not, what should the rest of the world do?

  • Is that just another hypothetical to have ago at the Muslim? — Διός , Thu Jul 12 12:01am
    I think it is, but what are you talking about, the pyramids have been plundered for millenniums the inner booties were the first to go by the real raiders. The outer skins were next. The majority of... more
    • Not at all... there have been some — Sprout, Thu Jul 12 9:22am
      current actions destroying pre-Islamic ruins in other nations, by radical Muslims. And in several cases the local gov'ts are allowing it to avoid conflict with this group of violent individuals.... more
  • If there's anything — greenman, Wed Jul 11 5:02pm
    ...that could bring me to call for a nuclear airburst over Mecca, that might be it. Religious fanatics, whatever their faith, are a threat to mankind. Fanaticism needs to be suppressed.
    • Or a neutron bomb? — Truthteller, Wed Jul 11 6:56pm
      I'd consider this before I see them actually destroy the pyramids, which I consider sacred: Neutron Bomb Plan against Terrorist States Sam Cohen has struggled against politicians who, in his opinion, ... more
      • I was kinda joking — greenman, Thu Jul 12 5:42pm
        ...nuclear weapons horrify me. Admittedly, the neutron bomb would eliminate worthless humans, but as to collateral damage, I'd have to believe there'd be a lot wherever you fired one off.
        • While a neutron bomb has "less" blast damange — Sprout, Fri Jul 13 7:00am
          it's all relative. A neutron bomb still has mutiple kilotons worth of blast effect... Not the megaton range of big fusion bombs, but still blast effects on the same scale as Hiroshima.
  • In that UNLIKELY event, we can laugh as they — David F Mayer, Wed Jul 11 4:10am
    kill their tourist trade. Not a $mart move. David F Mayer
    • Somewhat sad laughter though because — Sprout, Wed Jul 11 7:11am
      without that money it becomes only a matter of time before the rest of the world ends up having to feed the people that tourism would otherwise have fed.
  • Considering past actions — ChristopherBlackwell, Tue Jul 10 6:31pm
    Sprout, Look at the past Remember when the Chinese were destroying anything that was before Communism. What did we do about it. Nothing. When it started happening in Afghanistan? Again nothing.So if... more
    • There is something of a difference of scale though... — Sprout, Wed Jul 11 7:10am
      IMO the only thing China has that matches the scale of the Pyramids is the Great Wall... the tombs and history destoryed in Afghanistan, Mali, Sudan, etc... are all on a FAR smaller scale and far... more
  • Re: Destroying the Pyramids... — et, Tue Jul 10 5:25pm
    Help provide them with the C4? What they trying to hide? How bad peasants must had had it in that day?
  • We can't stop all the bad stuff in all the countries. — Ken C, Tue Jul 10 4:06pm
    We've already invaded too many countries, so I don't think we should send the military over there to stop them. Offering to pay them to not destroy the pyramids would be similar to paying terrorists. ... more
  • I wouldn't bet a penny... — Truthteller, Tue Jul 10 3:42pm
    that they will really do this. Tourism is a major source of income for Egypt and it would suffer greatly if there were no pyramids to visit.
    • I'm not sure it would be a national decision... — Sprout, Wed Jul 11 5:29am
      One of the challenges that occurs when religious fanatics end up with political power is that they often put their beliefs ahead of the finanical best interests of the whole. The ancient tombs being... more
  • difficult — Trish, Tue Jul 10 1:21pm
    Sovereignty of a land is something that humans have struggled over for years. To loose such great treasures IMO equals the loss of the Library at Alexandria (well, not quite as big but you... more
Click here to receive daily updates


Religion and Ethics BBS