Year 6 reorsification
Tue Mar 7, 2017 02:34

Hi Kim and Jaime:

G3, 232, I: year 6, II Peret 7: the vizier, general and 1PA Herihor ordered the reosirification of Menmaatre Sety-mererptah
G3, 263, 5, I: fine linen made by the 1PA Menkheperre in year 6 (on the body of Sety I)
G3, 264, II: year 7, II Peret 16, day of burying Sety I.

Kim wrote: The logical conclusion is that this particular Menkheperre, however scant his attestations, is a predecessor of Herihor as 1PA (the year 6 of his record need not be the same year 6 of Herihor's record). A later rewrap under "the" Menkheperre would have removed the statements of Herihor and replaced them with more recent orders to re-osirify.
As you have yourself found, fitting a year 6 into the career of "the" Menkheperre is quite awkward and requires special pleading. There are of course "radical" alternatives but these involve moving Herihor even further down the timeline, and I am not sure these are viable.

I would point out that Ritner says some of these reburials may have in fact been "official plunderings" by the HPA, rather than his pious concern to correct an earlier tomb robbery.

If we assume HPA Herihor ordered the plundering of Sety's tomb under the guise of reorsification, its quite possible reorsification never actually happened, or was not properly carried out, until some years later when Menkheperre was HPA. Sety was not re-wrapped by Herihor he was robbed by Herihor. Sety was not properly re-wrapped and properly re-buried until Menkheperre did this. He did not remove the statements of Herihor and replace them with more recent orders to re-osirify because the original order was never correctly carried out and only now was Menkheperre carrying them out.

I know this puts Herihor in a bad light, but when you badly need funds you do what you have to do.

Regards Tory

  • Re: Ramses XII = Ramses VIII?Jaime O, Mon Mar 6 13:44
    Hi Fabian, Kim, Tory I appreciate your kind replies. Here goes an extensive one. Fabian: I appreciate a lot your replies. You see, I like testing things and possibilities, even when they might be... more
    • Re: Ramses XII = Ramses VIII?Kim Sargerson, Sat Mar 11 04:49
      Hello Jaime "I might as well just leave some comments on that thread of ours. I've had some ideas on Pasenhor's genealogy..." Please do. I look forward to it, if you have the time. "I've read this on ... more
      • Re: Ramses XII = Ramses VIII?Jaime O, Sat Mar 11 14:06
        Hi Kim, Thank you for the reply. "Please do. I look forward to it, if you have the time." It won't be nothing new or inventive. As soon as I can get some more time and space, I'll type something. "I... more
        • Re: Ramses XII = Ramses VIII?Kim Sargerson, Tue Mar 14 18:38
          Hi Jaime "one needs to take account some of the genealogies that compose the backbone of the dynasty" As far as I can tell, only the Deir el Medina foremen seem to span the dynasty, and the... more
          • Re: Ramses XII = Ramses VIII?Jaime O, Wed Mar 22 09:33
            Hi Kim, forgive me for the extent of the last reply. This one might not be very different, so I apologize in advance. I wrote: "And we know from the Khonsu Temple that Herihor did act almost as king... more
            • Re: Ramses XII, and early Dyn 21Kim Sargerson, Thu Mar 23 13:26
              Hi Jaime You wrote "Exactly, which is why I do see Smendes coming between Ramses XI and Herihor as resolution to some problems, but may only be desirable until one comes up with something new." This... more
              • Herihor the HPA-kingTory, Mon Mar 27 23:48
                Hi all, The oracle of Herihor (Oracular Decree of High Priest Herihor, OIP3, p. 15, Plate 132) makes it clear that he was HPA for 30 years. 10 years as HPA had already elapsed when the oracle was... more
                • Early 21st DynastyJaime O, Wed Mar 29 08:43
                  Hi Kim and Tory Thank you for the replies. Kim: I do not think there is enough evidence to place Nesbanebdjed the king before or after Herihor the king. However, it still leaves a gap i.e. who was... more
                  • Early 21st DynastyJaime O, Thu Mar 30 13:45
                    There is an error in my previous tables, allow me to correct (and revise Menkheperre Bs tenure, presuming his Year 48 might be an error for something else): KINGS: - Ramses XI, 0-35 - Ramses XII,... more
    • Year 6 reorsification — Tory, Tue Mar 7 02:34
      • re: Year 6 reosirificationKim Sargerson, Wed Mar 8 18:24
        Hi Tory I have no doubt that the New Kingdom royals were indeed routinely plundered by these priests. It seems to have been a kind of "last resort", so they did a group in a short time, then there... more
        • re: Year 6 reosirificationTory, Thu Mar 9 08:12
          Hi Kim The way I see it, there is no need for yet another new person to be injected into this period. No Ramesses "XII" or Menkheperre "A". If there is a HPA Menkheperre "A" who reosirified Sety I,... more
          • re: Year 6 reosirificationKim Sargerson, Wed Mar 15 17:11
            Hi Tory Sorry has taken so long to reply. I didn't "get" this for the longest time, but: once the ATM withdrawal has been made, this particular source of revenue is gone. If Herihor cashed in Sety's... more
    • Re: Ramses XII = Ramses VIII?Fabian B, Mon Mar 6 14:22
      Dear Jaime, Thanks for your intelligent response. I am starting to think that Ramesses XII did exist too. As for Ramesses VIII, I do accept that he was a son of Ramesses III since it would explain... more
Click here to receive daily updates