Toby Anderson
Rohl, ramesses and Shishak
Tue May 8, 2018 15:08
2607:fb90:8512:f859:567:e551:c864:4ec3

Hello Marianne,

You wrote:
"Equating Ramesses II with Shishak is based on absolutely nothing credible."

Sound's like you've studied all the evidence including that presented by Rohl.

I request that you refute Rohl's evidence in some other manner than just giving your opinion.

Best,
Toby

Toby

  • re: RohlMarianne Luban, Tue May 8 11:54
    Toby wrote: "Below is my summary" Just briefly: "1. that the Egyptian Chronological timeline moves down. Ramesses II (circa. 1304-1236??? or 12791213???) of the 19th dynasty, instead of being the... more
    • A searchable site this is Anonymous, Tue May 8 15:11
      Marianne wrote in her reply to Toby: "This [the identity of the pharaoh of the exodus] has been discussed many times here. This is a searchable site." Anonymous II here: Yes, this is a searchable... more
      • Re: A searchable site this isMarianne Luban, Wed May 9 09:37
        Anonymous wrote: 'Marianne wrote in her reply to Toby: "This [the identity of the pharaoh of the exodus] has been discussed many times here. This is a searchable site." No, I specifically referred to ... more
        • Re: A searchable site this isAnonymous, Wed May 9 13:08
          In my post I wrote: "Marianne wrote in her reply to Toby: 'This [the identity of the pharaoh of the exodus] has been discussed many times here. This is a searchable site.'" Marianne wrote: "No, I... more
    • Rohl, ramesses and Shishak — Toby Anderson, Tue May 8 15:08
      • re: Rohl, ramesses and ShishakMarianne Luban, Wed May 9 12:18
        Toby wrote: "Hello Marianne, You wrote: "Equating Ramesses II with Shishak is based on absolutely nothing credible." Sound's like you've studied all the evidence including that presented by Rohl." I... more
        • Rohl Toby, Wed May 9 13:59
          Hello mariAnne I asked you to back up your statement. You made the statement the burden of proof is on you. I would be more than glad to provide the details as to why rohl argues that ramsesses birth ... more
      • Rohl, ramesses and ShishakJon Smyth, Tue May 8 18:31
        "I request that you refute Rohl's evidence in some other manner than just giving your opinion." Toby, the Assyrian chronology demonstrates the inadequacies of Rohl's Egyptian chronology. It was... more
        • Rohl, ramesses and ShishakToby Anderson, Wed May 9 22:13
          Hello Jon, Me (toby): "I request that you refute Rohl's evidence in some other manner than just giving your opinion." Jon: Toby, the Assyrian chronology demonstrates the inadequacies of Rohl's... more
          • Rohl, ramesses and ShishakJon Smyth, Thu May 10 15:40
            Hi Toby, you wrote: "Rohl is not arguing against the synchronisms between Assyria and Egypt. Nor is he arguing for or against the few synchronisms between Assyria and Israel. Rather, he is arguing... more
            • Rohl, ramesses and ShishakToby Anderson, Thu May 10 19:52
              Hi Jon, Toby wrote: "Rohl is not arguing against the synchronisms between Assyria and Egypt. Nor is he arguing for or against the few synchronisms between Assyria and Israel. Rather, he is arguing... more
              • Rohl, ramesses and ShishakJon Smyth, Fri May 11 16:11
                "Rohl is NOT condensing the Egyptian Timeline. You don't understand." Rohl is moving a Late Bronze Age Pharaoh 300 years forward into the Iron Age. I use to be a member of the New Chronology forum, I ... more
                • Rohl, ramesses and ShishakToby Anderson, Fri May 11 23:05
                  Hello Jon, You wrote: "Rohl is moving a Late Bronze Age Pharaoh 300 years forward into the Iron Age." That's what WikiPedia says. Wikipedia also says that Ramesses II died 1213bc. A typical... more
        • Rohl, ramesses and ShishakToby Anderson, Tue May 8 21:18
          Hello Jon, Me: "I request that you refute Rohl's evidence in some other manner than just giving your opinion." You: Toby, the Assyrian chronology demonstrates the inadequacies of Rohl's Egyptian... more
    • Bahr YusufMarianne Luban, Tue May 8 13:53
      Let's address this in a logical fashion. In ancient Egypt the canal was known as the "mr wr" or "great canal". There is nothing associating the Biblical Joseph with a canal in the Torah or the... more
      • Re: Bahr YusufMarianne Luban, Tue May 8 14:00
        Correction--Eusebius did mention some more detains about the agricultural contributions of Joseph: "(1) Artapanus says, in his book Concerning the Jews, that Joseph was a descendant of Abraham and... more
        • Re: Bahr YusufToby Anderson, Wed May 9 22:05
          I stand corrected about the canal. Toby
Click here to receive daily updates