Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
Rod McInnes
Colin S. MacDonald
Sat Jan 22, 2011 06:44
192.148.117.81 (XFF: 10.213.72.125)

Valerie,

In Australia, Graham MacDonald of Gympie has a copy which I believe he got from Colin direct back in the 1950s. He very generously loans it for copying. I made an uncollated PDF copy, which with a bit of work could be useful.

I also tried the National ArchIves, and got the same answer. I can't imagine that Colin would have wanted it locked up like this, though as an institution I understand that the Archives have to have rules. Better these discussion groups which allow us to share informally until somebody publishes.

Rod McInnes

  • Colin S. Macdonald's bookValerie Smith, Fri Jan 21 01:27
    I am aware that the Typescript of "Clanranald Macdonalds of Moidart" by Colin S. Macdonald (Nova Scotia)is available at Armadale and also in the National Archives Edin, where I was told that it could ... more
    • Colin S. MacDonald — Rod McInnes, Sat Jan 22 06:44
      • the clanrenald macdonalds of moidartwilliam f. callahan, Thu Jul 5 02:08
        how can i read this manuscript.thank you.
      • Colin MacDonald's bookValerie Smith, Sun Jan 23 00:50
        Thank you Rod, I do know Grahame and will seek out a copy. I did read the copy held in the National Archives Edin and had I my laptop there all would be resolved. I do have to wonder why a transcrip... more
    • Colin S. MacDonaldAllan J. Gillis, Fri Jan 21 05:23
      Valerie, There were copies of Colin's manuscript in the Nova Scotia Archives, St. Francis Xavier University Library and the Beaton Institute in Sydney. It has been very valuable as a research tool to ... more
      • Colin Macdonald's bookValerie Smith, Fri Jan 21 06:46
        Thanks Allan, have just spent the weekend up at Roshven View Arisaig now inspired to get back working on some Kinlochmoidart research. A Ranald McDonald b.1794 at Camus an Raoigh, died Victoria... more
        • GenealogyAllan J. Gillis, Fri Jan 21 08:24
          Hi Valerie, You were at Roshven View? Were you with Elizabeth and Allan MacDonald? Cheers, Allan
          • Colin Macdonald's bookValerie Smith, Fri Jan 21 09:40
            I certainly was, my annual visit for possibly the past ten years, searching bookshelves and past notes taken by Allan and Elizabeth...they are indeed treasurs of Moidart, and I only wish we could... more
Click here to receive daily updates