Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
Tomash
Tomash's thoughts: The Dispossessed
Thu Jul 5, 2018 7:01pm
47.184.23.21

So, I'd gotten on a minor Ursula K. Le Guin kick earlier when someone pointed me at The Left Hand of Darkness. This led me to read The Dispossessed, and now I can come by with some hopefully somewhat coherent thoughts on it.

The plot: it exists, and there are sufficient amounts of it that you're reading a story and not a pile of worldbuilding calling itself a novel. (That is, this is not a Neal Stephenson book, but it does veer in that direction on occasion.)

However, the plot really isn't the point of the book. The point is to deliver on the subtitle "An Ambiguous Utopia". We get the contrasts between Annares (a planet of anarchists) and Urras (the nearby planet they'd left because that's how the revolution ended up getting resolved). The narrative structure (which alternates chapter-by-chapter between Shevek's time on Urras and the backstory that led him there) as well as the viewpoint character (Shevek, a physicist who ran into some of the problems with the society on Annares) gives us a good view of the upsides and downsides of both an anarchist society and much more typical places. (For example, even without laws, you're still likely to end up with some form of power structure and "laws" enforced by social consensus. On the other hand, down on Urras there's, say, a lot of poverty, sexism, capitalist/socialist "democracies" - this was written during the Cold War, that sort of thing.)

Overall, The Dispossessed basically presents some ideas about how society could work and doesn't hit you over the head too much with a desired conclusion (sure, it might have a pro-anarchist lean, but it's not being blatant about it). Personally, I didn't walk away too sold on the concept of this form of anarchism - it felt somewhat unworkable and that a lot of the problems inherent in power structures this system was meant to solve were still rather present on Annares. But I'd recommend people interested people read for themselves and reach their own conclusions.

- Tomash, posting rambling thoughts on some book he read because why not

    • Other that the subject of the above post, I read Brief Cases (the Dresden shorts Thoth reviewed down-board) lately. I also picked up Caves of Qud (post-apocalyptic/surreal roguelike which Larf can... more
      • I think the first season of Daredevil was the last TV series I watched before I started reviewing everything on the Board, so I'll go over that here in addition to season two. Spoilers for both... more
      • Have I mentioned that I willingly read children's literature sometimes? Not young adult fiction, but like, overt children's books. Because I do that. Because I am a glutton. Because I have no shame.... more
      • This was the first of the Marvel Cinematic Universe movies that my mom went to see with us! She really enjoyed it, too. I don't know if she would be into the more serious movies as much, but the... more
      • First, to answer Tomash’s question: I just finished The Valley of Horses , which I’ll go into below. I’m nearing the end of the second season of Daredevil , and might be finishing that tomorrow,... more
        • I think that's as far as I got, myself. This was back in high school, so my memory of it isn't great, but my sense is that the tone continues to change from what it was in the first book, and for me, ... more
          • I'm glad you read my reviews, though!doctorlit, Mon Jul 9 1:07pm
            I know my reading in particular is often pretty random novels that most folks don't know, so I often feel I'm just writing for the drawer when I post these. So thank you! If you ever feel like a... more
      • I can rave about that. Larfen J. Stocke, esq., Sat Jul 7 11:12pm
        Caves of Qud is bloody great and it has great lore. It's probably what got me into New Weird, to be honest. Hell, one of the lore books was written by a sentient plant called Baccata Yewtarch. For... more
      • Recent reading. Hieronymus Graubart, Fri Jul 6 11:41am
        Freefall . Thanks for recommending this, I love it. Darths and Droids . I would probably enjoy this even more if I remembered more of Star Wars , and since I never watched Rogue One , I’m now totally ... more
      • Vacation readingAC, Thu Jul 5 11:15pm
        It being vacation, I've been reading a whole lot of things. A standout was The Goblin Emperor , by Katherine Addison. It too is more focused on world-building and characters than plot, but it's... more
        • Two things:Snowblaze, Fri Jul 6 4:33am
          One is YA fantasy (like a very large percentage of the stuff I read). It’s called Caraval and for once “Nothing is what it seems” is (almost) literally true. I had to read it twice before I could get ... more
  • Click here to receive daily updates