Court rules in favor of capital defendant in Magwood
Thu Jun 24, 2010 9:13pm
DISCLOSURE: Howe & Russell and Akin Gump represented the petitioner in this case.
Federal habeas law generally allows prisoners to bring a single habeas petition; “second and successive” petitions are highly disfavored and must meet very strict criteria. This morning, the Court held in Magwood v. Patterson (No. 09-158), that when a criminal defendant succeeds in having his original sentence overturned, a later habeas petition challenging his new sentence should be treated as a first petition (not as a “second or successive” petition), even if it raises grounds that could have (but were not) made against the original sentence. Writing for himself and Justices Stevens, Scalia, Breyer, and Sotomayor, Justice Thomas explained that under the text of the federal habeas statute, when a prisoner is resentenced and appeals the new sentence, he is challenging a different judgment than was challenged in his prior habeas petition. Justice Kennedy, joined by the Chief Justice and Justices Ginsburg and Alito, dissented.
What constitutes a “second or successive” petition in habeas challenges to death sentences? Magwood v. Patterson, argument recap Anna Christensen | Friday, March 26th, 2010 10:00 am Here, Harvard Law ... more
Court rules in favor of capital defendant in Magwood Britta,Thu Jun 24 9:13pm
A federal appeals court has overturned the death sentence given to an Alabama death row inmate for the 1979 shooting of a county sheriff in Alabama. The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Monday... more
This I find wrong in appeal cases they have to make all grounds for appeal in the first twelve months after conviction. Most defendants are uneducated and don't have access to good legal advice, yet... more
You are so right! It embarrasses us as being Americans with these injustices and the death penalty. You never know for sure the person is guilty. That is why they need to ABOLISH the Death Penalty... more
Appeal courts are not the safeguard people think they are, I find most appeals never see the light of day unless the innocence group (or similar groups) are backing the claims or if public opinion is ... more
I have to agree Darlie Routiers case is full of holes. What the prosecutor did was attack Darlie has a mother I think that's what ultimately convicted Darlie...lies and more lies... Let's hope truth... more