MT:Convicted killer Ronald Smith may be saved from execution
Thu Dec 23, 2010 04:03
Convicted killer Ronald Smith may be saved from execution by Montana lawmakers BY RANDY BOSWELL, POSTMEDIA NEWS DECEMBER 22, 2010 5:05 PM
After a stay of execution for Alberta-born killer Ronald Smith was upheld last week by Montana's top court, a lawyer for the only Canadian on death row in the U.S. says the reprieve could buy Smith enough time for the state to abolish the death penalty — something Montana legislators almost did last year.
A Montana Supreme Court ruling last Tuesday scuttled a Jan. 31 execution date that had been set in early November by a district court judge. Instead, the top court backed an earlier court decision that blocks Smith's execution pending the outcome of a 2008 lawsuit — filed on his behalf by the American Civil Liberties Union — over the state's lethal-injection method of capital punishment.
The postponing of the execution, a member of Smith's three-man legal team told Postmedia News, raises the possibility that Montana's state legislature could revive and approve abolition legislation before a new date is set for the Canadian inmate's execution.
"This stay may allow sufficient time to have the 2011 legislature consider the abolition bill this session," said Helena-based attorney Ron Waterman, a well-known figure in Montana's legal community who ran unsuccessfully in 2008 to become the state's attorney general.
The abolition bill, which passed the state Senate in 2009 but was defeated in a 10-8 vote by a House committee, would have retroactively replaced Smith's death sentence with a term of life imprisonment with no chance of parole.
But it's not clear that abolitionist forces in Montana's legislature could succeed in rewriting the law before Smith's death sentence is carried out.
One of the key issues raised in the ACLU lawsuit — the cramped and under-equipped state of a converted trailer used for recent executions — appears to have been addressed by the completion of a new facility at the prison where Smith has been held for nearly 30 years.
"Construction of the annex to the maximum-security building at Montana State Prison was completed last week," Bob Anez, a spokesman for the Montana Department of Corrections, said Wednesday.
But other problems cited in the Smith-ACLU lawsuit, including the training of those involved in executions and protocols for administering the lethal mixture of drugs, still face scrutiny in court.
The 53-year-old Smith was convicted of killing two young Montana men — Blackfeet Nation members Thomas Running Rabbit and Harvey Mad Man — during a drunken hitchhiking trip to the U.S. in 1982. Smith, a Red Deer, Alta., resident who was travelling with two other Canadians at the time, shot Running Rabbit and Mad Man in the Montana woods and stole their car.
Smith initially requested to be put to death, but later changed his mind and began a long-running legal effort to avoid execution.
The ACLU-backed lawsuit describes Montana's lethal-injection system as a "cruel" and "inhumane" procedure that would violate Smith's constitutional rights.
The civil case is now the last legal avenue available to the Smith to avoid the death penalty.
Earlier this year, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear an appeal of Smith's death sentence, ending decades of attempts by the Canadian's lawyers to win him a reprieve through the criminal courts.
Apart from the lethal-injection lawsuit and the potential abolition bill, Smith's only other chance of avoiding execution rests with efforts by the Canadian government to convince Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer to commute the death sentence.
Canadian diplomats were pressing for clemency in 2007 when the Conservative government controversially declared an end to the lobbying and introduced a new hands-off policy toward Canadians on death row in the U.S. and other democratic countries.
But the Federal Court of Canada, ruling last year on another Smith lawsuit challenging the Canada's clemency reversal, ordered the federal government to re-launch its efforts to save the convicted killer's life, in keeping with Canada's own abolition of capital punishment in 1976.
Canadian on death row in U.S. down to last legal remedy The Canadian Press Date: Monday May. 17, 2010 CALGARY — It's been a quarter-century of legal battles and court hearings, and now the only... more
Governor says request for clemency only one factor for death row Canadian Published Sunday October 3rd, 2010 Bill Graveland, The Canadian Press The man who could hold in his hands the life of the... more
Montana schedules Canadian's execution for Jan. 31 The Associated Press Wednesday, November 3, 2010; 2:48 PM DEER LODGE, Mont. -- A Montana judge has scheduled a Jan. 31 execution date for the only... more
Countdown to Canadian's execution By MICHAEL PLATT, QMI AGENCY Last Updated: November 4, 2010 7:05am Two cheeseburgers, fries, a half-gallon of ice cream, and two bottles of Dr. Pepper. It was the... more
State, defense say execution should be delayed DECEMBER 7, 2010 HELENA (AP) — Attorneys for the state and for death-row inmate Ronald A. Smith are asking the Montana Supreme Court to block his Jan.... more
Only Canadian on U.S. death row to make clemency plea? Published On Sun Mar 20 2011 Bill Graveland The Canadian Press CALGARY—The lawyer for the only Canadian on death row in the U.S. says a plea for ... more
DEATH PENALTY Safety net remains for Canadian on death row Calgary— Globe and Mail Update Published Friday, Jan. 06, 2012 9:27PM EST A legal challenge of how Montana carries out its death penalty... more
Only Canadian on U.S. death row gets clemency hearing CBC News Posted: Feb 9, 2012 7:48 PM ET Last Updated: Feb 9, 2012 7:45 PM ET A clemency hearing has been set for two days in early May for the... more
The Canadian Press - ONLINE EDITION Outgoing Montana governor taking no action on clemency application from Ronald Smith By: Bill Graveland, The Canadian Press 7/01/2013 12:53 PM | Comments: 0 Print... more
Hope for Canadian on death row as Montana execution protocol to be put on trial By Bill Graveland, THE CANADIAN PRESS October 20, 2012 Ronald Smith is shown on Feb. 22, 2012, at Montana State Prison... more
Canadian on death row awaits answer to his challenge of the use of lethal injection BILL GRAVELAND CALGARY — The Globe and Mail Published Tuesday, Jul. 31 2012, 9:12 PM EDT A legal challenge of how... more
July 13, 2012 Montana governor meets family of death row Canadian By Matt Gouras The Associated Press HELENA, Mont. – Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer on Friday told the family of a Canadian on death... more
Bad news for Canadian: Montana death penalty stays The Canadian Press Date: Saturday Mar. 19, 2011 CALGARY — A proposal to abolish Montana's death penalty has failed, spelling more bad news for... more
Alberta killer's U.S. death sentence caught up in legal maze BY RANDY BOSWELL, POSTMEDIA NEWS DECEMBER 10, 2010 Alberta-born killer Ronald Smith, the only Canadian on death row in the U.S., may have... more
MT:Convicted killer Ronald Smith may be saved from execution Petra.,Thu Dec 23 04:03
Montana AG files brief in Montana execution case Posted: Dec 14, 2010 9:45 AM by Beth Saboe (KPAX News) Updated: Dec 14, 2010 9:45 AM HELENA - Montana Attorney General Steve Bullock says that Helena... more
Montana Supreme Court asked to decide on conflictin execution orders in death-row case By Matt Volz (CP) – November 12, 2010 HELENA, Mont. — One district judge set a Jan. 31 execution date for a... more
Ottawa's support carries weight for Canadian on death row Ashley Wiebe 6/5/2010 The lawyer for the only Canadian on death row in the U-S says Ottawa's support will carry a lot of weight if his client ... more
"And while the two majority judges confirmed Smith's death penalty, they acknowledged the Canadian's initial lawyer "failed to investigate Smith's mental state at the time of the crime, and failed to ... more