Capital punishment: an offence against victims' relatives
Fri Apr 8, 2011 11:28
Capital punishment: an offence against victims' relatives
For grieving families hoping for closure as well as justice, the death penalty with its endless delays and appeals can be cruel • Maura Kelly • guardian.co.uk, Thursday 7 April 2011
On Tuesday, death row inmate Cleve Foster was granted his second stay of execution this year. His first came on 11 January, just moments after Foster – who maintains he is innocent and would have been the first Texan executed with a cocktail containing a chemical used to euthanise animals – had eaten what he believed was his last meal; that's when the call came, informing him that the US supreme court would consider an appeal.
The parents of Rachel Urnosky, a 22-year-old woman whose murder Foster was charged with (though never tried for, being found guilty instead of a related homicide), found out about the decision after making a long trip across the "lone star state", when they arrived at the prison where Foster's execution was supposed to take place. Terry Urnosky, Rachel's father, a therapist, told The Texas Star-Telegram how shocked he felt:
"It's like – if you've ever played football – getting hit in the stomach with a helmet in the gut. […] We were expecting closure. But unfortunately, we're reliving all the thoughts, the trials, the evidence. […] The nightmare continues."
Death penalty proponents argue that executions help victims' family members feel that justice has been done, and indeed, Terry Urnosky said back in 2003 that he thought the death sentence was part of God's plan for Foster. But others who've endured similar tragedies oppose the capital punishment, arguing that the agonising appeals process that so often accompanies a death penalty case exacerbates their pain and, far from helping them overcome their loss, keeps it in the forefront of their minds.
No judge wants to be responsible for allowing the execution of an innocent person, which helps explain why there tend to be an unusually high number of appeals in a capital case. But appeals are costly – and not just figuratively, for victims' families, but literally, for taxpayers. North Carolinians, for instance, pay $2.16m more for every death row inmate than for those sentenced to life, and Florida spends $51m more annually than it would if life-without-parole were the most severe sentence allowed there.
More to the point, the long, slow appeals process exacts a toll from victims' families. Sure, some survivors do say things like, "I was really looking forward to sitting in the front row while they executed this guy," (as Karen Bond told the Chicago Tribune after Illinois Governor Pat Quinn commuted her son's murderer's sentence). But others want the criminals who ruined their lives to get nothing less than … life. For instance, last month 82 relatives of murder victims signed an open letter to Connecticut lawmakers, saying:
"The death penalty is a false promise that goes unfulfilled, leaving victims' families frustrated and angry [and] wastes millions of dollars that could go toward much needed victims' services."
Similarly, Laura Porter from Equal Justice USA, a grassroots organisation working to improve the justice system, increase services for families of homicide victims and repeal the death penalty, says:
"I work with many murder victim's family members […] and I'm hearing more and more voices calling for repeal of the death penalty, citing the fact that the endless appeals process harms victims."
Or take it from Walter Everett, a 76-year-old retired minister whose son was killed when a crack addict shot him point blank. He recently told the Connecticut Post:
"There is an incredible cost of the death penalty […] emotionally for families of victims because they tend to wait seemingly forever, for the execution."
That doesn't sound just. Emotional closure is going to be difficult, under any circumstances, for people who have suffered as he and the Urnoskys have. But the legal case, at least, is more likely to be closed quickly if it's a question of a life prison sentence rather than a penalty of death.
Patrick Knight, executed June 26, 2007, "Yes, I do. I thank the Lord for giving me my friends, for getting me the ones I love. Lord reach down and help innocent men on death row. Lee Taylor needs... more
Kentucky native in line for execution in Texas Larry Johnson, The Record Newspapers Published 01/08/2011 - 6:21 p.m. CST A former oil field worker, Cleve “Duke” Foster, 47, is the next death row... more
Ex-recruiter's execution for 2002 Fort Worth slaying is halted at last minute Posted Tuesday, Jan. 11, 2011 Express your opinion in a letter to the editor By Michael Graczyk The Associated Press... more
Victims' families distressed by delay of Cleve Foster's execution Posted Friday, Jan. 14, 2011 BY TIM MADIGAN firstname.lastname@example.org Assured by officials that convicted killer Cleve Foster had... more
Capital punishment: an offence against victims' relatives Petra.,Fri Apr 8 11:28
Supreme Court lifts stay of execution in Fort Worth slaying Posted Tuesday, Jan. 18, 20110 BY TIM MADIGAN email@example.com The U.S. Supreme Court today denied the appeal of condemned killer ... more
New execution date set for death row inmate Last Update: 1/28 10:35 pm A new execution date has been set for a death row inmate charged in the murder of a Texas Tech student and convicted of killing... more
Apr 4th, 2011 Posted by Anna Arceneaux, Capital Punishment Projectat CAPITAL PUNISHMENT Texas Execution Tomorrow Risks Needless Pain and Suffering Tomorrow, Texas plans to execute Cleve Foster using... more
State secrets Why are Texas authorities in such a hurry to execute this prisoner? Copyright 2011, HOUSTON CHRONICLE April 4, 2011, 8:52PM Texas inmate Cleve Foster is due to be executed this evening, ... more
Death Row Inmate Seeks Reprieve Over Drug Method By TIMOTHY WILLIAMS Published: April 4, 2011 A former Army recruiter convicted of killing a woman he met in a Fort Worth, Tex., bar nine years ago is... more
Supreme Court Issues Stay of Execution By TIMOTHY WILLIAMS Published: April 5, 2011 The United States Supreme Court on Tuesday morning granted a temporary stay of execution to Cleve Foster, a former... more
Tuesday, April 5, 2011 The U.S. Supreme Court Has Stopped Today's Scheduled Execution of Cleve Foster in Texas The United States Supreme Court on Tuesday morning granted a stay of execution to Cleve... more
EDITORIAL A Horror at Every Turn Published: April 7, 2011 Cleve Foster, a former Army recruiter convicted of murder, was scheduled to be executed earlier this week in Huntsville, Tex., when the... more
Supreme Court frees Texas to set new execution date for man convicted in Ft. Worth killing By Associated Press, Updated: Tuesday, May 31, 2011 WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court has lifted its hold on... more
Today is third execution date for ex-Army recruiter in 2002 killing Posted Monday, Sep. 19, 20112 BY TIM MADIGAN firstname.lastname@example.org For the third time this year, former Army recruiter Cleve... more
Fourth execution date set in 10-year-old Fort Worth rape-murder Posted Tuesday, Jun. 19, 2012 A former Army recruiter from Fort Worth who was granted three stays of execution in 2011 now has a fourth ... more
Texas inmate prepares for 3rd trip death house Sunday, September 23, 2012 | Updated: Sunday, September 23, 2012 1:29pm LIVINGSTON, Texas (AP) — What Cleve Foster remembers most about his recent... more
4th execution date Tuesday for Texas inmate Monday, September 24, 2012 | Updated: Monday, September 24, 2012 1:25pm LIVINGSTON, Texas (AP) — Attorneys for former Army recruiter Cleve Foster went to... more
Texas inmate narrowly avoided execution 3 times, tries for fourth By Molly Hennessy-Fiske September 24, 2012, 12:13 p.m. HOUSTON -- A Texas inmate whose appeals have three times spared him the death... more
Texas Death Row Inmate Seeks Fourth Stay of Execution • by Brandi Grissom • September 25, 2012 Death row inmate Cleve Foster, a former military recruiter, is hoping the courts will for the fourth... more
Court declines to halt execution for Fort Worth rape-slaying Posted Friday, Sep. 21, 20120 HOUSTON -- A federal appeals court has declined to stop next week's scheduled execution of a former Army... more
Supreme Court halts ex-Army recruiter’s Texas execution for 3rd time in rape-slaying of woman By Associated Press, Published: September 20 | Updated: Wednesday, September 21, 7:51 AM HUNTSVILLE,... more
Execution of woman's killer still being challenged Posted Saturday, Apr. 02, 2011 BY MELODY MCDONALD email@example.com More than nine years ago, on Valentine's Day, construction workers... more
damn... do debate about this torture receive 3 execution dates and stopping the murder an hour before in one year. Cleve Foster, 47, known as "Sarge" on Death Row, had eaten his final meal and was... more
Texas' switch in execution drugs warrants proper review Posted Monday, Apr. 04, 2011 A state-administered execution isn't supposed to inflict as much pain and horror on the convicted killer as the... more
Death Row inmate loses two decisions in effort to stop execution Posted Monday, Apr. 04, 20111 BY MELODY MCDONALD firstname.lastname@example.org Attorneys for Texas Death Row inmate Cleve Foster,... more
Execution Set for April, But State Out of Key Drug • by Brandi Grissom Judges have set the dates for four more executions this year, and all of them scheduled to take place after the state's supply... more
Sister of a Henderson Man on Death Row Speaks Out Reported by: Drew Gardner January 26, 2011 The family of a Henderson man sitting on death row in Texas is speaking out to FOX 7. They are revealing... more
Henderson County, Kentuck, native is scheduled to be executed tonight in Texas. A jury found Cleve Foster guilty in 2004 of the rape and murder of a 28-year-old woman in Fort Worth. Foster claims he... more