EDITORIAL A Horror at Every Turn Published: April 7, 2011
Cleve Foster, a former Army recruiter convicted of murder, was scheduled to be executed earlier this week in Huntsville, Tex., when the Supreme Court rightly granted a stay pending a review of his case.
There are so many reasons why the death penalty should be repealed everywhere. It is barbaric, and a terrifyingly high number of innocent defendants have been placed on death row or executed. Mr. Foster’s petition makes a strong case that, but for his ineffective state-appointed trial lawyer, he would not have been sentenced to death and that the evidence against him leaves conspicuous room for doubt about his guilt. It also makes a strong case that, but for the weakness of a second state-appointed lawyer who filed a writ of habeas corpus, he would have been granted a new trial.
The Supreme Court must decide whether Texas violated Mr. Foster’s rights by providing an ineffective habeas lawyer. The answer must be, “Of course.” Otherwise, the state will be allowed to pretend to satisfy his right to be heard while callously denying it. “This is my Life,” Mr. Foster wrote the lawyer when he fired him. “I feel you treated me Like a Dog.”
The means for Mr. Foster’s planned execution are also tainted. Last month, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice said it would use pentobarbital as the sedative in place of sodium thiopental in the state’s three-drug lethal injection protocol. (Spookily, in apparent violation of federal law, it was sent using a federal license number registered to the Huntsville Unit Hospital, which was shut down in 1983 because of its abysmal treatment of prisoners.)
Rick Thaler, director of the Correctional Institutions Division, made the switch to the new, unproven protocol without consulting any doctors or other medical professionals. Also in apparent violation of federal law, the prison system is not following prescribed steps to safeguard the drug to ensure there is no tampering.
The suffering of any inmate during execution is inexcusable. The execution of an innocent person is an even greater horror. The Supreme Court should give Mr. Foster the chance to prove his innocence.
Tuesday, April 5, 2011 The U.S. Supreme Court Has Stopped Today's Scheduled Execution of Cleve Foster in Texas The United States Supreme Court on Tuesday morning granted a stay of execution to Cleve... more
TX: A Horror at Every Turn Petra.,Sat Apr 9 07:08
Supreme Court frees Texas to set new execution date for man convicted in Ft. Worth killing By Associated Press, Updated: Tuesday, May 31, 2011 WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court has lifted its hold on... more
Today is third execution date for ex-Army recruiter in 2002 killing Posted Monday, Sep. 19, 20112 BY TIM MADIGAN firstname.lastname@example.org For the third time this year, former Army recruiter Cleve... more
Fourth execution date set in 10-year-old Fort Worth rape-murder Posted Tuesday, Jun. 19, 2012 A former Army recruiter from Fort Worth who was granted three stays of execution in 2011 now has a fourth ... more
Texas inmate prepares for 3rd trip death house Sunday, September 23, 2012 | Updated: Sunday, September 23, 2012 1:29pm LIVINGSTON, Texas (AP) — What Cleve Foster remembers most about his recent... more
4th execution date Tuesday for Texas inmate Monday, September 24, 2012 | Updated: Monday, September 24, 2012 1:25pm LIVINGSTON, Texas (AP) — Attorneys for former Army recruiter Cleve Foster went to... more
Texas inmate narrowly avoided execution 3 times, tries for fourth By Molly Hennessy-Fiske September 24, 2012, 12:13 p.m. HOUSTON -- A Texas inmate whose appeals have three times spared him the death... more
Texas Death Row Inmate Seeks Fourth Stay of Execution • by Brandi Grissom • September 25, 2012 Death row inmate Cleve Foster, a former military recruiter, is hoping the courts will for the fourth... more
Court declines to halt execution for Fort Worth rape-slaying Posted Friday, Sep. 21, 20120 HOUSTON -- A federal appeals court has declined to stop next week's scheduled execution of a former Army... more
Supreme Court halts ex-Army recruiter’s Texas execution for 3rd time in rape-slaying of woman By Associated Press, Published: September 20 | Updated: Wednesday, September 21, 7:51 AM HUNTSVILLE,... more