TX:Forensics report on Willingham case advances good science
Tue Apr 19, 2011 15:42
Forensics report on Willingham case advances good science Posted Monday, Apr. 18, 20110
Members of the Texas Forensic Science Commission last week sidestepped the most incendiary issue facing them, but in doing so they focused attention on important recommendations for improving the criminal justice process.
A report has been expected for months on whether the commission found negligence or professional misconduct by investigators who concluded that Cameron Todd Willingham started the fire that killed his three young daughters in 1991.
The panel's conclusions on that issue could have broad ramifications not just for arson prosecutions in Texas but for the death penalty debate because Willingham was executed in 2004, though he insisted he didn't set the fire.
But commissioners are awaiting an attorney general's opinion on whether they have jurisdiction over cases predating the body's 2005 creation.
As a result, the lengthy report they approved Friday dealt largely with general findings derived from extensive hearings into the Willingham case.
The report reflects careful, thoughtful work by scientists and lawyers dedicated to the proper use of accurate forensics in criminal prosecutions.
The commission's efforts had been overshadowed by claims from competing sides that politics threatened to steer the outcome and by debate over whether Texas wrongly executed Willingham.
But this report, at least, provided evidence that the extended time spent on the case allowed commissioners to hear helpful additional testimony, ask probing questions and thoroughly deliberate difficult issues about developments in arson science.
They concluded science progresses but most active investigators don't have scientific background or needed resources -- and that should change.
The report said "there was no uniform standard of practice for state or local fire investigators in the early 1990s in Texas or elsewhere in the United States." But, since the National Fire Protection Association first published a set of investigation standards in 1992, they have been revised and become more widely accepted.
Texas arson investigators should be trained in the most current techniques and proper application of the scientific method, the commission said.
For instance, much more is known today about determining where a fire started, looking at whether electrical wiring malfunctioned and examining burn patterns to assess whether accelerants were used.
The commission called for a code of ethics; recommended that new data about fire science experiments be effectively disseminated; and said investigators should be better trained in documenting their debris analysis and preserving records.
A debris analysis report from the Willingham case couldn't be found.
Commissioners also recommended that standards be developed to reexamine cases "when science has evolved to create a material difference in the original analysis or result."
The state has an obligation to get things right, especially when there's no going back.
Willingham arson report comes before panel this week By Chuck Lindell | Wednesday, April 13, 2011 During a two-day meeting to begin Thursday afternoon, the Texas Forensic Science Commission will... more
Bassett: Politics Stymied Willingham Investigation • by Aziza Musa April 18, 2011 The former chairman of a state forensic board applauded the current commissioners' report on the arson investigation... more
Texas Forensic Science Commission Approves Arson Recommendations Determination of negligence in Willingham arson case still pending On Friday April 14, the Texas Forensic Science Commission made real ... more
Film questions Texas death penalty arson case December 7, 2011 -- Updated 1427 GMT (2227 HKT) (CNN) -- Throughout "Incendiary," a new award-winning documentary, filmmakers pose a tough question with... more
INCENDIARY the willingham case http://www.incendiarymovie.com/INCENDIARY/INCENDIARY.html Please join the Houston Peace and Justice Center (www.hpjc.org) for a special screening of: INCENDIARY 8pm,... more
Fire Officials Urged to Revisit Old Cases Forensic Science Commission nears close of Willingham investigation BY JORDAN SMITH, FRI., APRIL 22, 2011 Members of the Texas Forensic Science Commission... more
Willingham case spurs panel's call for reform Commissioners looked into investigations that critics say were flawed and sent a Corsicana dad to his execution By ALLAN TURNER HOUSTON CHRONICLE April... more
Texas forensic panel plans to release Willingham report this week Posted Wednesday, Apr. 13, 20110 BY DAVE MONTGOMERY firstname.lastname@example.org AUSTIN -- The Texas Forensic Science Commission is... more
Willingham report released By Chuck Lindell | Thursday, April 14, 2011, 12:09 PM A draft report issued today by the Texas Forensic Science Commission on the evidence used to convict and execute... more
Michael McLaughlin email@example.com Cameron Todd Willingham Exoneration Was Written But Never Filed By Texas Judge Posted: 05/19/2012 8:01 am Updated: 05/19/2012 2:29 pm A Texas... more
Family requests pardon review for executed man CHRIS TOMLINSON, Associated Press Wednesday, October 24, 2012 | Updated: Wednesday, October 24, 2012 12:40pm AUSTIN, Texas (AP) — The family of a man... more
Effort continues to examine Texas arson convictions Posted Saturday, Aug. 04, 2012 BY YAMIL BERARD firstname.lastname@example.org Texas criminal justice watchdogs are examining records from hundreds of... more
Myths and Facts about the Willingham Case Cameron Todd Willingham’s case raises strong opinions on many different levels, but some who defend his conviction and execution are distorting aspects of... more
Willingham case puts spotlight on forensic analysis Posted Saturday, Apr. 30, 20110 BY YAMIL BERARD email@example.com One Oklahoma forensic chemist was so prolific in implicating criminal... more
Bradley out as head of Texas forensics panel By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS May 25, 2011, 4:47PM TDCJ Cameron Todd Willingham was executed in 2004 for setting a fire that killed his three daughters. AUSTIN... more
Perry Chooses New Forensic Science Board Chairman • by Brandi Grissom July 1, 2011 Gov. Rick Perry today announced he has appointed Dr. Nizam Peerwani, a well-known Fort Worth medical examiner, to... more