OR: The 2,000-year-old reasoning against the death penalty
Tue Jul 19, 2011 14:28
The 2,000-year-old reasoning against the death penalty holds today Published: Tuesday, July 19, 2011 By Guest Columnist "Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed." (Genesis 9:6)
By Rabbi Daniel Isaak
Death row convicted murderer Gary Haugen has demanded an end to all appeals. If he is determined sane to make such a decision, his will become the first Oregon execution in 14 years. Twice Oregonians voted to outlaw the death penalty, and in 1981 the Oregon Supreme Court declared the state's law illegal. The penalty was re-instituted by voters in 1984. Oregon is one of 34 states that retain capital punishment.
The Bible explicitly prescribes death for both moral and religious violations: premeditated murder, kidnapping, adultery, idol worship, witchcraft, blasphemy, Sabbath violation, being a stubborn and rebellious child (!) and a great number of improper sexual liaisons. And though death remains on the books in Jewish judicial law, 2,000 years ago the rabbis of the Talmud, who were given authority to interpret God's will, relegated this ultimate punishment to theory, rather than practice. They stated their position with great clarity: "A Sanhedrin (rabbinic court) that puts a human being to death once in seven years is called destructive"; others say "even once in seventy years"; still others professed that "were it up to them none would ever have been put to death."
Revealing a basis of Jewish anxiety over the death penalty, legal scholar Maimonides in the 12th century claimed, "It is better to acquit a thousand guilty persons than to risk putting a single innocent person to death."
By adding countless stringencies to the rules of evidence, the rabbis formally rendered the death penalty moot. Convictions require the testimony of at least two unrelated eyewitnesses knowledgeable in the law. They must explicitly warn the accused as to the nature of the crime about to be committed as well as explain the prescribed punishment. The perpetrator would in turn need to acknowledge the warning, but claim that he intended to engage in the violation nevertheless and immediately commence performance of the crime. The court would interrogate the witnesses separately. Even the most insignificant discrepancy would render their testimony invalid. The rabbis were aware that with such requirements no court could impose the ultimate punishment.
Today we anguish over the justice of the death penalty not only because, despite safeguards, the real possibility remains of executing an innocent individual. We also understand that convicted people of color are statistically far more likely to be sentenced to death than whites, particularly if the victim is white. Further, we cannot escape the reality that the poor invariably receive an inferior defense when compared with those who can pay attorney fees.
The revulsion many of us feel about society putting a human being, no matter how depraved, to death is no less than the rabbis who sought to do God's will 2,000 years ago.
Daniel Isaak is a rabbi at Congregation Neveh Shalom in Southwest Portland.
Hearing set to evaluate death row inmate Haugen Judge to weigh the findings of mental evaluation A Marion County judge on Wednesday set a Sept. 27 hearing to evaluate the mental competence of death... more
State does practice lethal injection to prepare for possible execution of death row inmate Gary Haugen Published: Tuesday, August 16, 2011 By Helen Jung, The Oregonian State corrections officials... more
Judge to decide on inmate's execution wish Monday, September 26, 2011 PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — Death row inmate Gary Haugen could find out Tuesday whether a judge will grant his wish to be executed, a... more
“On the Row, You Never See the Stars”: Oregon Prisoner Wants to Die to Escape Death Row October 21, 2011 tags: death row phenomenon, Death Row Syndrome, Gary Haugen, Oregon death row by Sal Rodriguez ... more
Convicted killer seeks to hasten execution in Oregon September 27, 2011 | 3:40 pm Seeking to end the lengthy process of appeals and delays that have postponed his execution--recently set for Aug. 16... more
Gary Haugen: Tentative Dec. 6 execution date set for death row inmate Published: Friday, October 07, 2011, 9:45 AM Updated: Friday, October 07, 2011, 10:06 AM By Helen Jung, The Oregonian SALEM --... more
Gary Haugen's Death Warrant: http://www.scribd.com/doc/73164327/Haugen-s-Death-Warrant Judge signs Haugen death warrant Nov. 18, 2011 A Marion County judge today signed a death warrant for condemned... more
Gary Haugen describes life on death row He slams governor for granting reprieve 1:03 AM, Dec. 30, 2011 Oregon's best-known death row inmate is mired in a familiar rut as he awaits a new year. Gary... more
Monday, April 02, 2012 | 8:41 PM Marion County DA backs Gary Haugen's argument to override Kitzhaber on execution By Helen Jung | The Oregonian Gary Haugen may have found a courtroom ally in his... more
Death Row Inmate Sues to be Executed Sunday, June 17, 2012 Gary Haugen Oregonian Gary Haugen is having trouble making up his mind whether he wants to live or die. The 49-year-old prisoner has been on ... more
Gov. John Kitzhaber stops executions in Oregon, calls system 'compromised and inequitable' Published: Tuesday, November 22, 2011, By Helen Jung, The Oregonian Bruce Ely / The Oregonian Gov. John... more