VA: The Justin Wolfe Case: We Await His Full Exoneration
Wed Aug 3, 2011 17:04
Monday, August 01, 2011 The Justin Wolfe Case: We Await His Full Exoneration July 18, 2011 By Ron Keine
It's been 10 long years. Justin Wolfe's mother, Terri Steinberg, is living proof that persistence and determination pay off. I hope other mothers and family members of those wrongfully convi c ted take note of her triumph in doggedly pursuing justice for Justin. She is living proof that there is always hope for the wrongfully convicted. I want to be the first one to congratulate Justin on his vindication in U.S. District Court and for the decision by Judge Raymond A. Jackson to overturn his death sentence. Every so often I come across a case that is so horrible, and so politically corrupt, that it totally renews my determination to stop the terrible injustice that is the death penalty in our country. It makes me more aware of why I do what I have been doing for so many years: working to stop our government from killing its own citizens. In Virginia it is called the " Trigger Man Law". In Texas they call it the "Law of Parties". In Illinois it is known as the "Law of Accountability". Whatever the different states call it, it has been used by prosecutors for years to charge people like Justin with felony or capital murder, and sentence them to death.
This is a horrible, nonsensical, and arbitrary law designed to give prosecutors the ability to legally push for killing people who did not kill anybody. Not being satisfied with executing the actual murderer, they also get to kill the person who didn't pull the trigger, but was merely present at the scene of the crime, or who is even only suspected of involvement on the basis of the false testimony of the actual killer, as in Justin's case, for the same crime. Often the actual murderer will not receive the death penalty in exchange for implicating others, like Justin, who then get sent to death row instead. In a nutshell, the law means that an accomplice can be executed for any felony which he or she was involved in, and a death occurred as a result. For example, if two guys steal a car and the driver uses it to purposely run over and kill a foe, the courts can also send the passenger to death row, even if he did not know the driver was going to kill somebody. Under this law, stealing a car is a felony crime and if a death resulted, it is punishable by death.
Another example is if a man robs a store and any death occurs, the getaway driver can also receive a death sentence, even though he never entered the store. And this means any death at all. If the store owner panics and shoots a customer, cop, or an innocent bystander, the prosecutor gets to charge both the robber and the getaway driver with capital murder. He can even be allowed to argue for a death sentence for someone who loaned gas money to the robbers, knowing they were going to rob a store. This is not even close to the "an eye for an eye" justice that many death penalty supporters claim as their rationale for keeping the death penalty on the books in the United States.
Justin Wolfe , a mere teenager, was sent to death row under this law. Justin’s marijuana supplier was killed. The confessed killer said that Justin told him to do it. With that as the only evidence against him, Justin was convicted of murder and sent to death row to await his execution, while the actual killer got a lighter sentence. The killer later confessed that he lied and said Justin had nothing to do with it. It took ten years of heartbreaking struggle for Justin and his family to finally get the case overturned. In doing so, they also found out that the corrupt prosecutor knew Justin was innocent all along, and withheld this exculpatory evidence that would prove Justin innocent, a blatant Brady Violation. It is typical that the prosecutor in Justin’s case has already blustered that he intends to retry Justin. In these cases, prosecutors, rather than admitting defeat and malfeasance, will try to stall an exonoration by saying that he is considering a retrial.
However, in this case he has no evidence because his only witness is flip flopping on whether Justin had a part in the murder. He has nothing to bring in a new trial. Corrupt prosecutors will most likely offer Justin two options. One is to fight for a few years longer for his freedom and complete exoneration; the other is to pressure Justin to cop a plea to a lesser charge related to the murder in exchange for time served.
However, I will bet a dime to a dollar that the prosecutor will not find enough evidence to retry Justin, especially since it is clear that exculpatory evidence had been suppressed at the first trial, and Justin will eventually be exonerated. Even though Justin will remain in jail a while longer while the prosecutor continues to stonewall justice, we are hopeful he will one day soon join our family of exonerated death row survivors and their loved ones.
Ron Keine is Assistant Director of Communications and Training at Witness to Innocence, the nation's only organization founded by and for exonerated death row survivors.
Families feel the death penalty, too By JONATHAN HUNLEY Published: September 05, 2010 PRINCE WILLIAM COUNTY, Va. - Terri Steinberg was frustrated. It seemed like she wasn’t going to get to see her... more
Justin Wolfe's mother hopes 11-year ordeal is nearing an end By: KEITH WALKER | InsideNova Published: May 22, 2012 FAIRFAX, Va. -- After 11 years, Terri Steinberg finally has reason to hope that her... more
For Immediate Release: August 16, 2012 CONTACT: Margot Friedman at 202-332-5550 firstname.lastname@example.org U.S. COURT OF APPEALS VACATES CONVICTION AND DEATH SENTENCE OF JUSTIN WOLFE... more
Wolfe Appeal Granted, Conviction Vacated Chantilly man was on death row for a decade; triggerman recanted testimony against Wolfe. By Dusty Smith | July 12, 2011 Justin Michael Wolfe’s conviction and ... more
Murder Conviction Most Foul What Justin Wolfe's case in Virginia tells us about death row cases everywhere. By Dahlia Lithwick Posted Thursday, July 14, 2011, at 4:42 PM ET Almost 10 years ago,... more
VA: The Justin Wolfe Case: We Await His Full Exoneration Petra.,Wed Aug 3 17:04
Virginia to appeal ruling that tossed ‘02 death sentence in drug dealer’s murder-for-hire plot By Associated Press, Published: August 8 RICHMOND, Va. — The Virginia Attorney General’s office plans to ... more
U.S. judge overturns Culpeper capital murder conviction By: FRANK GREEN | The Daily Progress Published: February 29, 2012 Citing police and prosecutorial misconduct, a federal judge has tossed out a... more
Ex-judges, prosecutors backing Va. death row inmate Justin Wolfe Justin Wolfe has been on death row since 2002, convicted in a murder-for-hire case involving a high-end northern Virginia drug ring.... more
Another Death-Row Victory for Wolfe Federal judge vacates murder and drug convictions, plus sentences. By Bonnie Hobbs Sunday, August 26, 2012 #Centreville — Message from the court system to Prince... more
Criminal Defense Attorney Thomas Soldan On Latest Development In Justin Wolfe Case PRWeb Defense Attorneys Ask For Immediate Release. (PRWEB) November 23, 2012 A high-profile death row case (Case No. ... more
Va. judge orders release of capital murder defendant by Thursday unless appeals court steps in By Associated Press, Updated: Wednesday, January 2, 2:03 PM MANASSAS, Va. — A Virginia judge has ordered ... more
Appeals court blocks Wolfe's release Posted: Thursday, January 3, 2013 4:36 pm | Updated: 6:02 pm, Thu Jan 3, 2013. BY FRANK GREEN Richmond Times-Dispatch A federal appeals court blocked the release... more
Va. won't appeal decision vacating death sentence Justin Wolfe could become the first wrongfully convicted inmate freed from Virginia's death row since DNA evidence cleared Earl Washington in 2000.... more
Despite Vacated Conviction, Death Row Inmate May Still Serve Decades Even without murder charges, Justin Wolfe faces 20 years—while dealers up the chain now walk free. • By Dusty Smith • July 20,... more
Virginia reevaluates DNA evidence in 375 cases By Mary Pat Flaherty, July 17, 2011 Just over two years ago, William and Cynthia Bennett were viciously attacked as they went for a Sunday morning... more