Oregonian Gary Haugen is having trouble making up his mind
Sun Jun 17, 2012 12:44
Death Row Inmate Sues to be Executed Sunday, June 17, 2012
Oregonian Gary Haugen is having trouble making up his mind whether he wants to live or die. The 49-year-old prisoner has been on death row since 2007 for fatally beating and stabbing fellow inmate David Polin in 2003, while Haugen was serving a life sentence without parole for beating his ex-girlfriend’s mother to death in 1981. Both crimes were exceptionally violent: Polin’s skull was crushed and he had been stabbed 84 times.
Originally scheduled to die August 16, 2011, Haugen waived his appeals to protest the “arbitrary and vindictive nature of the death penalty,” but the Oregon Supreme Court cancelled his execution because Haugen’s attorneys argued that he was mentally incompetent to waive his appeals. After a hearing found him competent, he was scheduled to die December 6, when Oregon Governor John Kitzhaber announced he was granting Haugen a reprieve from execution, and that he would not allow any executions to proceed, at least until the state legislature has a chance to consider and enact reforms. Kitzhaber called Oregon’s death penalty system “compromised and inequitable.”
Haugen initially thought Kitzhaber’s action “was a smash, [that] something good was done,” and his attorneys filed papers accepting the Governor’s reprieve. Within a short time, however, Haugen changed his mind, calling the Kitzhaber “a paper cowboy” who “couldn’t pull the trigger.” He was particularly critical of Kitzhaber’s decision to submit possible reforms to the 2013 State Legislature, rather than in 2012; that decision likely flowed from the fact that the legislature meets for only 35 days in even numbered years but for 160 days in odd years.
Now Haugen wants the courts to force Kitzhaber to allow his execution. In a lawsuit filed May 24, Haugen’s new attorneys argue that a pardon or reprieve must be accepted by the inmate to be valid, and that Haugen’s prior attorneys did not have his consent to file papers welcoming the reprieve. They also argue that Governor Kitzhaber exceeded his constitutional authority in granting the reprieve, because a reprieve is ordinarily time-limited, rather than open-ended.
The lawsuit may face rough going, however, as it relies on two very old cases (from 1918 and 1926) for its “acceptance” argument, and cites only a 43-year-old legal dictionary for the proposition that the Governor can issue only time-limited reprieves. Neither the Oregon Constitution nor relevant statutes place any such restrictions on the Governor’s power.
To Learn More:
Death Row Inmate Demands Execution (by Dee Moore, Courthouse News Service)
Haugen v. Kitzhaber, Complaint Filed in Court (pdf)
Correspondence from Attorney Harrison Latto to Governor John Kitzhaber (pdf)
Gov. Kitzhaber’s Reprieve of inmate Gary Haugen’s Execution was Legally Valid, DOJ Argues (by Helen Jung, The Oregonian)
The 2,000-year-old reasoning against the death penalty holds today Published: Tuesday, July 19, 2011 By Guest Columnist "Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed." (Genesis 9:6) ... more
Hearing set to evaluate death row inmate Haugen Judge to weigh the findings of mental evaluation A Marion County judge on Wednesday set a Sept. 27 hearing to evaluate the mental competence of death... more
State does practice lethal injection to prepare for possible execution of death row inmate Gary Haugen Published: Tuesday, August 16, 2011 By Helen Jung, The Oregonian State corrections officials... more
Judge to decide on inmate's execution wish Monday, September 26, 2011 PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — Death row inmate Gary Haugen could find out Tuesday whether a judge will grant his wish to be executed, a... more
“On the Row, You Never See the Stars”: Oregon Prisoner Wants to Die to Escape Death Row October 21, 2011 tags: death row phenomenon, Death Row Syndrome, Gary Haugen, Oregon death row by Sal Rodriguez ... more
Convicted killer seeks to hasten execution in Oregon September 27, 2011 | 3:40 pm Seeking to end the lengthy process of appeals and delays that have postponed his execution--recently set for Aug. 16... more
Gary Haugen: Tentative Dec. 6 execution date set for death row inmate Published: Friday, October 07, 2011, 9:45 AM Updated: Friday, October 07, 2011, 10:06 AM By Helen Jung, The Oregonian SALEM --... more
Gary Haugen's Death Warrant: http://www.scribd.com/doc/73164327/Haugen-s-Death-Warrant Judge signs Haugen death warrant Nov. 18, 2011 A Marion County judge today signed a death warrant for condemned... more
Gary Haugen describes life on death row He slams governor for granting reprieve 1:03 AM, Dec. 30, 2011 Oregon's best-known death row inmate is mired in a familiar rut as he awaits a new year. Gary... more
Monday, April 02, 2012 | 8:41 PM Marion County DA backs Gary Haugen's argument to override Kitzhaber on execution By Helen Jung | The Oregonian Gary Haugen may have found a courtroom ally in his... more
Oregonian Gary Haugen is having trouble making up his mind Petra.,Sun Jun 17 12:44
Gov. John Kitzhaber stops executions in Oregon, calls system 'compromised and inequitable' Published: Tuesday, November 22, 2011, By Helen Jung, The Oregonian Bruce Ely / The Oregonian Gov. John... more