Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
Merlin
Memo to Democrats: Upholding Norms Is a Two-Way Street
Fri Sep 7, 2018 7:17am
24.228.93.156

I think that the Senate Democrats should ask Anonymous if he/she could lend them a hand to resist succumbing to their worst inclinations.

https://www.nationalreview.com/2018/09/kavanaugh-confirmation-hearings-democrats-flout-senate-norms/

At the Kavanaugh confirmation hearings, Senate Democrats have undermined the decency they claim to uphold.

Many of the current president’s critics on the left insist that they are standing up for norms of democratic conduct and for democracy itself. Some are sincere. Neal Katyal, for example, who served as principal deputy solicitor general in the Obama administration, endorsed Neil Gorsuch for the Supreme Court. Liberal feminist lawyer Lisa Blatt penned an op-ed in Politico praising Brett Kavanaugh. Her standard, she wrote, was whether the nominee was “unquestionably well-qualified, brilliant, has integrity, and is within the mainstream of legal thought. Kavanaugh easily meets these criteria.”

But the Democratic members of the Senate judiciary committee have this week undermined the norms of decency they claim to uphold. They have contributed to the sense that things are out of control.

The opening of the Kavanaugh hearing was a circus. One after another, Democratic senators, starting with Kamala Harris of California, interrupted and talked over the committee’s chairman as he was welcoming the nominee. “Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman. We cannot possibly move forward.” Senator Richard Blumenthal moved to adjourn the hearing and was echoed by Senators Hirono and Booker. At the same time, scads of protesters arose, at carefully timed intervals, to screech their incoherent bile at the entire process. They were escorted out. Chairman Grassley must have been tempted to ask the sergeant-at-arms to offer the same treatment to Harris et al. In fact, the Republicans must have been tempted to accept the Democrats’ challenge and cancel the hearing altogether. The Republicans have the votes and can simply report out Brett Kavanaugh’s nomination to the floor. If they did, the Democrats would lose their soapbox. The final outcome — a foregone conclusion in any case — would not be affected.

The only Democrat to object to this descent into chaos was Senator Dianne Feinstein. In a nod to the zoo-like tenor of the hearing, she told Kavanaugh, “I’m sorry for the circumstances but we’ll get through it.” For this, she was predictably skewered by progressives.

Next, New Jersey senator Cory Booker flamboyantly violated Senate rules (the penalty for which can include expulsion from the body) by releasing some of Kavanaugh’s emails that were deemed “committee confidential.” Booker, whose first name might as well be “likely presidential candidate,” chose his subjects with all the subtlety of a jackhammer. One email contained Kavanaugh’s caution to George W. Bush’s transportation department that a particular program looked like a “naked racial set-aside.” Booker implied that Kavanaugh’s use of the term implied racial insensitivity, but in fact, the Supreme Court had ruled set-asides to be invalid, so it was completely sensible for the staff secretary, a lawyer and former Supreme Court clerk, to alert the agency that it was on shaky legal ground. The other email Booker waved about like a bloody shirt bore the subject line “racial profiling.” This email, dating from the early post-9/11 era, apparently contains Kavanaugh’s recommendation — drumroll please — that the government refrain from racial profiling!

If Booker has made a fool of himself, and flouted Senate procedures in the process, most of his Democratic colleagues bought in too. As Booker himself crowed after several of his colleagues, including minority leader Chuck Schumer, weighed in on his behalf, “This is about the closest I’ll ever have in my life to an ‘I am Spartacus’ moment.” Someone also took the step of leaking many other emails to the New York Times.

Kamala Harris, in the most peculiar exchange with the nominee, darkly implied that Kavanaugh had some nefarious connection to someone who worked at a law firm founded by Trump’s lawyer Marc Kasowitz. Kavanaugh was perplexed, but clarified the following day that he had no connections of any kind to that firm. Harris’s sinister insinuations look both bullying and foolish.

If you’re truly concerned about norms, surely the rules of the Senate and ordinary civility and respect for one’s opposition should rank high. Yet Democrats were content to stoke absurd suspicions that Kavanaugh had snubbed the father of one of the Parkland shooting victims, when any benefit of the doubt would have shown that it was simply a case of an unknown man approaching him and security intervening to usher him away. And in the fever swamps of the Left, the accusation of a “white power” symbol blazed across Twitter for a few hours.

Some of us take our lumps holding our own side to account. The Democrats need to reflect seriously on the fact that norms are more than a cudgel to use against Republicans.







    • I Will Say This... ~ Amadeus, Fri Sep 7 9:32am
      I'm not endorsing any particular action, especially those of the Democratic senators on this committee. Were I to do so, I would be looking for effective action as opposed to actions that ultimately... more
      • Everything you state the Repubs have been doing have been done and are being done by Democrats today. In many cases they are the first to engage such actions. (SEE: The origins of Gerrymandering -... more
        • Take Gerrymandering, For Example... ~ Amadeus, Fri Sep 7 2:38pm
          I despise it. Done here, done there, it's wrong no matter who does it. However, when you devise a national strategy to use state level control to enact gerrymandering on a wide scale to entrench that ... more
      • Well said. It's true. ~ G👏🏾👏🏾G, Fri Sep 7 10:05am
        Both parties are hypocrites.
      • are actions that ultimately undermine their positions, not effective action. Playing at political gamesmanship in terms of playing aggressively, bending but not bending the rules and sharp practices... more
        • You seem to suggest the demonstration ~ G👁G, Fri Sep 7 8:53pm
          are not of the people? Right or left, the People rightly speak wherever when galvinized to do so. I rather enjoy Code Pink. I do not care which idealogy so long as their right to protest reasonably... more
        • Like I Said... ~ Amadeus, Fri Sep 7 11:12am
          I'm not endorsing any particular actions in this context. I'm separating those from the general issue of upholding norms and whether it is the job of Democrats to do this on their own without the... more
        • Well said! (nm) ~ TW, Fri Sep 7 11:07am
    • Kavanaugh is a surprise. ~ G🤔G, Fri Sep 7 8:21am
      From what small bits and pieces I have garnered from listening to snipits of these proceedings, Kavanaugh is not a pushover. He is clear headed, knows his profession, and has an emotionally steady... more
    • sense of decorum and propriety. As if one's feelings carry far more weight than common sense and good taste. In fact, it's obviously just the opposite. The Bible covers that as it does just about... more
  • Click here to receive daily updates