Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
Bob Goodwin
Response
Tue Dec 5, 2017 5:48am
73.228.72.237

Vince, I did respond. see my post subject: "Freckleton" in the original string. No one seems to have responded to that one. Of course, you could always email me and ask.

So after the Wilcox robbery, and being chased through Wyoming, Utah, and Colorado, SK does not resurface until just before the Tipton and Winnemucca robberies. That is almost a year. I don't know where he was, or what he was up to. I was just wondering if anyone else knows either? I am also wondering what he was up to when he left Logan and Currie for a few days while the posse was chasing them through North central Wyoming. He just ups and disappears for a few days, then comes back before they get to the Anderson Hog ranch.

  • Why did Bob ask about SD and Wilcox?Vince Garcia, Tue Dec 5 2:44am
    He usually asks questions like that when he has some sort of new info he's discovered, and made no response to replies, so I'm wondering...
    • Response — Bob Goodwin, Tue Dec 5 5:48am
      • Frackelton Pat, Tue Dec 5 10:07am
        Let the record show that Frackelton wrote mostly a fictional account . He did not get to Andersonville until after the main outlaws had left. He did not meet SD there nor Logan or anyone else of... more
        • AndersonvilleBob Goodwin, Wed Dec 6 6:17am
          So Currie and Curry both went through Andersonville and Old Thermopolis after the Wilcox robbery. Was there another person/robber with them? If Sundance was not with them, where did he go? Did he... more
          • Re: AndersonvillePat, Wed Dec 6 7:30am
            Bob , Flat Nose George Currie did not go to Andersonville. He headed west as you know . Who was with Harvey Logan when he went northwest to Andersonville.? Could have been Harvey Rey, Tom O'Day,... more
            • The moneyBob Goodwin, Thu Dec 7 4:24pm
              So Sundance apparently was not at Andersonville, or at least did not come with Logan and the others. I am still puzzled as to how Bob Lee got some of the Wilcox money. He said that the man he knew as ... more
        • Sundance Encounter Mark, Tue Dec 5 10:10pm
          Your saying that account and dialogue between Longabaugh and frackelton is not true ? I find it hard to believe that passage in his bio would be made up. He works in the town as the dentist. Just... more
          • MarkPat, Tue Dec 5 10:38pm
            Frackelton spent all his time in Sheridan prior to early spring 1897 when he went to Alaska to seek gold.. Sundance was in MT and Canada and back in MT in the years prior to the Belle Fourche robbery ... more
        • FrackletonBob Goodwin, Tue Dec 5 3:31pm
          Pat, So you are saying that Frackleton didn't know what he was talking about, and he made most of it up. Also that Logan and Currie came through Andersonville and Old Thermop. but not Sundance? If... more
          • Dr. Will FrackeltonMark Mszanski, Wed Dec 6 8:39am
            I have read the passage again . I believe Dr. Frackelton is accurate in whom he is meeting with . He bumps into the WB and encounters - Sundance, Butch , Tom Oday and ( The Perry Boys ???) and... more
            • The Perry Boys?Mark Mszanski, Thu Dec 7 6:10am
              The question for all is who does Dr. Will Frackelton think the Perry Boys are? - Is this the Logans? Sincerely,
              • Re: The Perry Boys?Vince Garcia, Thu Dec 7 5:16pm
                Can't be the Logans. He met Harvey as Harvey, Lonie wasn't there but was at Thornhill's. I've heard it speculated one of the Perrys might have been the dynamite man at Tipton.
                • Yet another Mystery Mark Mszanski, Thu Dec 7 7:46pm
                  Vince - Kind of funny as he speaks of them as if everyone should know who they are - " Oh of course , The Perry Brothers" . Sincerely,
          • Re: FrackletonPat, Tue Dec 5 6:55pm
            Will Frackelton was a storyteller and wanted to make himself famous. He was born in 1870 in Milwaukee, Wi . Graduated Dental school and practised there until 1893. He then made his way to Sheridan... more
            • Seeley was his brother in law Mark, Tue Dec 5 10:18pm
              Pat. I find your interpretation Off. The dentist used his relative to help me pen the book. Tom O’Day did not convince frackelton that the guys at the bar were Butch and Sundance and Logan. That’s... more
              • Re: Seeley was his brother in law Anonymous, Tue Dec 5 10:36pm
                His brother in law recorded Will Frackelton ‘s memoirs as told to him. What is great about the book is that it is published in 1947 as the first revised edition and very little exists of interaction... more
                • Re: Seeley was his brother in law Vince Garcia, Wed Dec 6 2:47am
                  And he correctly--in opposition to what the public would have believed had they not seen the actual men in person interacting with the gang--that Logan was more the dominant personality and planner,... more
      • Re: ResponseVince Garcia, Tue Dec 5 7:19am
        oh, sry i didn't see it. I haven't gotten email alerts when i post for months so i sometimes don't notice responses. I'll go read it now
      • re:Bob Goodwin, Tue Dec 5 5:51am
        Maybe when he left Currie and Curry he just needed a "tickle."
Click here to receive daily updates