Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
Daniel Buck
Re: Its a miracle
Sun Apr 29, 2018 8:53am


The tea party photo has excellent provenance. A descendant of Sundance's sister Samanna Longabaugh shared it, along with a copy of the jinetes photo, with Wild Bunch researchers in the 1970s. (Unfortunately, the resolution of the copies is not good; they might even be thermofax copies, hard to tell.) As well, the descendants of a neighbor of the Wild Bunch trio has a copy of the jinetes photo.

The tea party photo was taken on the west side of the cabin and the jinetes on the east side. I've been on both sides of the cabin, and looked at photos of both sides taken before the early 2000s rebuilding. As well, BC&SK are wearing similar clothing to what they wore in the jinetes photo, and in the photo taken in Capiñata, Inquisivi, Bolivia, in 1908.

Finally, the San Vicente eyewitness Remigio Sánchez described the two bandits' noses as "medios ñatos," which our Bolivian translator said covers both BC&SK's noses. Dan

  • Re: Its a miracleJuha, Sun Apr 29 12:46am
    Well, looking at the Cholila tea party photo I can see Kid's nostrils...and he is looking straight at the camera, not at the sky.
    • Re: Its a miracle — Daniel Buck, Sun Apr 29 8:53am
      • DAN, OMG!Pat, Sun Apr 29 11:14am
        There is no provenance on the Tea party photo. It Donna pretending that some relative supposed found it 70 years AFTER it was sent. Now if the photos and diary were all lost and family couldn't... more
        • repeat after me: measure twice, cut onceDaniel Buck, Sun Apr 29 12:07pm
          Pat, Repeat after me: measure twice, cut once. Donna Ernst reproduced the tea party and jinetes photos in her 1992 book, Sundance My Uncle, published 25 years before she first went to Argentina. Dan... more
          • You have dementia DanPat, Mon Apr 30 8:22am
            You deny Lula or Jano but believe a lying thief like Donna because she is your friend. I still remember her coming up to Fremont country driving from Rock Springs right past me in Lander to my fiends ... more
            • tacos are North AmericanDaniel Buck, Mon Apr 30 9:13am
              Dear Pat, It's nice to know that the stroke has not affected your dyspepsia. Dan PS Tacos are a North American food, originally from Mexico, not South American. Details here,... more
          • Take Your Own Advice DanChrisV, Sun Apr 29 12:43pm
            You need to take your own advice One of many examples of your poor research is the Santiago Ryan signature published as authentic. Was DEBUNKED .....and so on.
      • Re: Its a miracleJuha, Sun Apr 29 10:36am
        Dan, I totally agree, I was just stirring the pot.
        • Re: Its a miracleDaniel Buck, Sun Apr 29 12:09pm
          Juha, understood. I was just summarizing the evidence for the OWR peanut gallery. Dan
          • Minecraftneglib, Sun Apr 29 5:28pm
            If you look closely it could be Steve or Alex. Take your pick. Brett
        • Reprimand from DanChrisV, Sun Apr 29 11:44am
          Careful Dan only likes Yes Men.
      • Two legit photos of SundanceChrisV, Sun Apr 29 9:06am
        Ive been over this cabin thing with you. Prove it. Show us pictures that line up with the cabin in the photo. We have two photos of Sundance that are 100% him. He has a roman nose, not a pug nose.... more
        • "medios ñatos," not pug noses. Daniel Buck, Sun Apr 29 9:11am
          Chris, Let's stick the the record: San Vicente eyewitness Remigio Sánchez described the two bandits' noses as "medios ñatos," not pug noses. Best, Dan
          • Brett Has a Great PointChrisV, Sun Apr 29 5:56pm
          • 1901 eyewitnessesneglib, Sun Apr 29 5:30pm
            Dan, What do the 1901 eyewitnesses in SOAM say about their noses? Best, Brett
          • Re: "medios ñatos," not pug noses. ChrisV, Sun Apr 29 9:27am
            Funny in the tea party photo it is a pug nose. Hmmmm. Medios natos would not include a roman nose. Hmmmm I think we all agree Fort Worth Five photo is Sundance. I think we all Agree the NY photo with ... more
    • Re: Its a miracleChrisV, Sun Apr 29 6:35am
      Then its not Sundance in the photo. Your born with an upturned nose. Sundance had a roman nose. Add on top of it the girl doesn't look like Etta and the guy doesn't look like Butch. The cabin in the... more
Click here to receive daily updates