Daniel Buck
Re: Magician's Trick
Fri Jun 14, 2019 10:00am
71.163.191.37

Rocky,
not to put too fine a point on it but people criticizing aspects of forensics are themselves scientists. In fact, one of the major reports was issued by the US National Academy of Sciences. Has nothing to do with the media; these are scientists talking.
https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/we-must-strengthen-the-science-in-forensic-science/

Second, just because something is as you say "used in court" does not make it accurate. Scientists have learned that such thinks as bite mark and blood spatter, long used in court, are junk science.

Regardless, even if the science is done properly, that's only the beginning, not the conclusion. The jury decides what's what. If you have ever watched a trail you know that the proceedings often involve competing expert witnesses who have differing opinions about the exact same evidence.

It's not a perfect system by any means, but more often than not a better verdict will result from the competing arguments.

Dan

  • Re: Magician's TrickRocky, Fri Jun 14 9:02am
    Dan, I am sorry I was not clear in my previous response. I have no problem with the conservative or liberal nature of the article. I have a problem with someone using a media article as scientific... more
    • Re: Magician's TrickDaniel Buck, Fri Jun 21 3:08am
      Rocky, "We need to fix forensics. But how?" Washington Post, 20 June 2019 https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/06/20/we-need-fix-forensics-how/?utm_term=.8784299e0973 The writer solicited... more
      • Re:Magician's TrickRocky, Mon Jun 24 5:14pm
        Dan, Are you sure you aren't the magician here? I appreciate the article in Scientific American. It's another media piece, regardless of where it was published, Scientific literature is from peer... more
        • Re:Magician's TrickDaniel Buck, Mon Jun 24 6:29pm
          "I also did some follow-up with Chris. I find it disingenuous for you to write an article debunking facial recognition and photographic analysis AFTER you had received a copy of the analysis and... more
    • Re: Magician's Trick — Daniel Buck, Fri Jun 14 10:00am
Click here to receive daily updates