Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
hinesjd
Re: Writing Prompts
Sat Jun 20, 2015 12:14
24.136.158.77

Agreed.

I think that learning to write should be a fun and creative experience that only free writing can provide. I think that we have to teach prompt responding for students to be able to pass school (i.e. the writing test, EOGs, etc.) and that is sad. I don't want to have to teach that to my students, but it seems almost required. I think that free writing is best to start out writing instruction with and then in the later years (once they have a strong foundation) begin to teach the prompt response writing.

  • Writing Prompts - tatem1, Thu Jun 18 23:38
    This module was tremendously helpful in molding my perspective in writing instruction. From reading previous posts, I believe this has been an eye-opening module for most of us. What stood out to me... more
    • RE: Writing Prompts - parsonkl, Sat Jun 20 19:14
      Personally, I feel in some cases that writing prompts can be beneficial to the students. If a student is struggling with what to write, a writing prompt can give them an idea to get started. I still... more
    • Re: Writing Prompts - Sonya Summey, Sat Jun 20 18:05
      In high school I was always given writing prompts. They were silly prompts like, "What if a silver back gorilla came into the room write now what would you do?" They were funny, but as you can tell I ... more
    • Writing prompts - luckadooso, Sat Jun 20 16:13
      I think that writing prompts are tricky. There are times, I think, where prompts can be helpful when helping students to learn a specific way of writing. I think that unstructured writing time can... more
    • Re: Writing Prompts - hinesjd, Sat Jun 20 12:14
      • RE: Writing Prompts - tatem1, Sat Jun 20 13:49
        Yes, I completely agree. Prompts should be kept to a minimum during instruction and introduced later on in order to get students to think independently first.
    • RE: writing prompts - Lauren Livingston, Sat Jun 20 11:32
      I couldn't agree with your post more how writing prompts limit the creativity of students with ASD. Writing prompts are a way that teachers can guide students in their writing. For students with ASD... more
      • RE: Writing Prompts - tatem1, Sat Jun 20 13:56
        I had never thought of using picture cues in place of verbal or written prompts. I can see how this can help kids with ASD. I wonder if picture cues are considered prompts. It is kind of a prompt but ... more
    • reply to Writing Prompts - Navila Castro, Sat Jun 20 10:44
      I completely agree with allowing students to write without prompts to promote independent thinking. I learned this week that allowing students free range and motivation helps much more than... more
      • RE: Writing Prompts - tatem1, Sat Jun 20 14:06
        I was given prompts throughout school too. I'm pretty sure they are still common place in public education and I doubt that the school system is trying to move away from using them. I would assume... more
    • Re: Writing Prompts - brownrf, Fri Jun 19 23:34
      I 100% agree with you...writing prompts don't allow for flexibility and creativity. I had an English class one semester and my teacher made us write every single class period for 10 minutes but we... more
      • RE: Writing Prompts - tatem1, Sat Jun 20 14:17
        I agree that "students enjoy writing more when they can write about things they want to." I believe this is key. If kids enjoy writing they are more likely to succeed at it. I'm so glad you had a... more
    • Free Writing - Amanda Wallace, Fri Jun 19 21:52
      I agree after being given prompts for so many years it is hard to suddenly be expected to write about anything and everything. I think free writing would be most beneficial when started early, so the ... more
      • RE: Writing Prompts - tatem1, Sat Jun 20 14:22
        YES, we can't expect students to think outside of the box when we have limited their ideas and creativity with prompts from the get go. They must first learn to think independently.
    • Re: Writing Prompts - andersenal, Fri Jun 19 14:38
      I agree with you in that I had trouble with writing when not given a specific prompt because my teachers always gave prompts throughout my schooling. I don't see the point in using prompts when we... more
    • prompts - catheyt, Fri Jun 19 08:38
      I thought this was interesting too. There are so many ways we can get our kids to write meaningful text without them becoming prompt dependent. BUT in a regular classroom kids have to write to... more
      • Prompts and Free Writing - Rachel Caldwell, Fri Jun 19 16:43
        I agree with you completely. I had never thought about how dependent I was on prompts and guided writing until I went through this lesson and these comments. I, like you, see the good in both. I... more
    • Reply to Marcela - Haley Brigman, Fri Jun 19 00:03
      Totally agree with you, I wrote a little about this as well. For your question about prompts, I think it's a good idea to have supports available for students who may be experiencing a writer's block ... more
      • Ways to get started - Cassidy Milosh, Sat Jun 20 09:00
        In one of the articles we read, I believe it was Dr. Koppenhaver's chapter, there's a comprehensive list of other ways to get past writer's block. Instead of having a prompt that guides writers to... more
Click here to receive daily updates