Lease this WebApp and get rid of the ads.
Daniel Buck
Re: Billy the Kid Mystery Solved!???
Sun Jul 29, 2018 13:49
71.126.136.67

Jerry. Thanks. I think I saw that image some time ago, but I do not recall the circumstances. Marc Geyer, the narrator and perhaps agent/seller for the photo's owner, is a tad misleading in dropping Brian Lebel's name. Lebel hosts shows that included many different vendors selling thousands of items. I think what Geyer meant to say -- that is, what he should have said -- is that he was a vendor at Lebel's show. Doubtful Lebel had any direct link to Geyer's photo. Nor, as you point out, does Geyer say what happened to the image, probably because no one bought it.

I agree the lad does not looks much like Billy. Nor does Geyer provide any convincing provenance.

Overlaying and morphing one photo into another, which takes up a chunk of Geyer's video, is not much more than a magic trick. At one point Geyer says that the "mouth is in the same area." Well, I suppose it would be on most people, below the nose and above the chin. He also says everything "completely lines up," which if you were watching closely was patently untrue. He's conducting an illusion.

In fact, even if they were the same person, not everything would line up. The nature of photographs generally, and even more true where one person is standing straight up and the other has a cocked head, arm on a rifle, and is slightly akimbo. Dan




  • Billy the Kid Mystery Solved!???Jerry Prather, Sun Jul 29 12:06
    For some reason, this popped up on my screen while I was looking at YouTube this morning. Since I had 15 minutes and 53 seconds to waste, I watched it. 100% of 80% of 60%, or whatever it is, will... more
    • High NoonPam Potter, Tue Jul 31 10:58
      I have been to a few of the High Noon Auctions but not sure which years. I was there in 2015 or 16. There was a guy set up with some pictures that we all walked by rolling our eyes. Because someone... more
      • At High NoonJerry, Wed Aug 1 05:32
        Hello Pam, I have only been to the High Noon event twice. Last time about a year and a half ago. I think you and Dan are correct that the photo was on display in a booth there and was not for sale in ... more
    • Re: Billy the Kid Mystery Solved!??? — Daniel Buck, Sun Jul 29 13:49
Click here to receive daily updates